News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Friday January 08, 2016 @12:48PM (#10866687)
If you can't see the reasons for someone's bad day, it is very difficult to empathize with them.
Re:How to fend off a jerk by DanielStraight on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:30PM (#10867023)
You can empathize with their feelings regardless the reason for them. If they are frustrated, you understand feeling frustrated, so empathize. If they are angry, you understand feeling angry, so empathize. The precise reason doesn't matter.
Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Friday January 08, 2016 @03:55PM (#10868163)
How can you know their feelings, if you do not know the reasons for their feelings? Empathy as understanding someone's frustration requires you to first know that someone is actually frustrated (otherwise you are just imagining).
Re:How to fend off a jerk by betenoire on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:19PM (#10868354)
Have you had a bad day? If so, then you can empathize with their bad day without knowing their reasons.

Personal note, empathy is SO much easier for me the less I know. If they share their problems, I instinctively start dissecting and analyzing their situation.. It's easier to just recognize suffering and to try not to contribute to it or lessen it.

Re:How to fend off a jerk by DanielStraight on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:14PM (#10868307)
I don't mean to be dismissive, but I really don't understand what you're trying to say. My understanding is that we are talking about face-to-face interaction with a clearly frustrated person. Why wouldn't you know they were frustrated?
Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Friday January 08, 2016 @08:42PM (#10869645)
I am talking about this situation:

>some times people are having a really bad day for reasons you can't see

It's not clear how you know someone is having a "really bad day" when you explicitly rule out knowing the reasons why the person is having a really bad day.

Maybe they told you they are having a really bad day? That is fine and fairly easy to empathize with.

Maybe you are just assuming someone is having a really bad day because of how you perceive their actions?

Re:How to fend off a jerk by mwfunk on Friday January 08, 2016 @06:40PM (#10869164)
You are using empathy in a different sense than (I think) most people are in this thread. I'm no psychiatrist, but usually when I hear people discuss empathy (or more often, someone's lack of it), they mean it almost in the sense of a lower-level mental process. Empathy is more than just feeling bad for random strangers who feel bad themselves- if anything, that's just a side effect. Empathy is the thing that makes you feel bad when you hurt someone else, even if you had a good reason for hurting that person. Empathy is the thing that allows you to sense other people's internal states- it's not magic or psionics or whatever, it's just your subconscious maintaining a background thread that is paying attention to signals from other people, and communicating those signals to you by internalizing a distant echo of what that background thread has determined that they must be feeling. It's fundamental to human interaction and cooperation and is (IMO) one the biggest drivers of the development of civilization.

A sociopath is an adult who never developed this facility. Children don't have empathy- it's one of the things that makes them children. That's why some kids do things like torture or kill animals...in their minds, those animals aren't creatures with sensory experiences like themselves, rather those animals (or even other people) are perceived as meat robots, for lack of a better term. Lacking empathy means when they hurt someone, they don't feel anything themselves because there is no background thread in their subconscious reminding them that the person they are hurting is another thinking, perceiving, feeling being like themselves.

Psychiatrists can't diagnose someone as a sociopath until they're 18, by which time people's brains are expected to have developed some capacity for it. People on the autistic spectrum also have a lesser capacity for empathy, that's part of what defines them as being autistic. They can't perceive subtle social queues because of this lack of empathy.

There are plenty of people who are self-aware, functioning sociopaths- they've spent their lives having fundamental social problems, never relating to other people the way that everyone else seems to be able relate to each other. At some point in life they discover that their cognitive development wasn't perfect, and once they understand the nature of the issue they can compensate by making a conscious effort to do so. There are also plenty of sociopaths who never made this leap, and basically all you can do is stay as far away from them as possible, because who wants to deal with someone who thinks you're a meat robot?

In the context of this thread, people aren't talking about sociopaths or anyone with autism/Asperger's/etc., but imagine a seemingly normal adult with underdeveloped empathy- it manifests in all sorts of ways, from being jerks to retail employees to stiffing waiters to just being an unpleasant person to interact with. Those people don't realize they have an underdeveloped cognitive process, they just go through life wondering why so many people think they're jerks, and saying things like "99% of humanity is way too sensitive". I would attribute a lack of self-awareness to a lack of empathy as well- if someone is incapable of seeing themselves through other people's eyes, then they have no way of gauging their own behavior or feelings.

Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Friday January 08, 2016 @08:50PM (#10869670)
In the context of this thread, I don't understand why you brought up either sociopaths or autism/Asperger's/etc., especially when you specifically disclaim it in your last paragraph.

I think the problem with this conception of empathy is that it seemingly derives solely from the person experiencing it. This type of empathy requires a subconscious background thread to be keeping track of signals which may or may not exist in the external reality. If it is at all possible to know (whether or not such signals exist), it would appear to at least require some communication. Otherwise you are just trying to make inferences off of what you observe, which is probably a near insignificant amount of what the person you are supposedly empathizing with has observed (leaving the question: How do you actually know that the things you are feeling are actually, exactly the same as what the other person is feeling?). I believe this definition of empathy allows people to feel good about themselves, that they are not a sociopath, while still allowing for the possibility that the empath is not actually feeling the same thing as their target.

Re:How to fend off a jerk by eseehausen on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:12PM (#10866882)
That depends on your initial assumptions, which you can shape over time (though you may not want to or find it advantageous to do so).
Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:17PM (#10866928)
Yes, you could engage in a conversation with the individual to better understand their situation. However, in the scenario presented:

>some times people are having a really bad day for reasons you can't see and a little bit of empathy goes a long way

I don't see how you can have much empathy. Patience, yes. Compassion, yes. Full sharing of feelings, no, purely by the description of the scenario.

Re:How to fend off a jerk by dsp1234 on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:26PM (#10866986)
This is just a case where the person said empathy, but meant sympathy. It's a common mistake to make.
Re:How to fend off a jerk by dktbs on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:33PM (#10867048)
This seems like a good example of this article posted yesterday: https://pchiusano.github.io/2014-10-11/defensive-writing.htm...
[dead]
Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Friday January 08, 2016 @03:51PM (#10868130)
I guess no one is trolling the personal attack ban hammer, at the moment.
Re:How to fend off a jerk by brazzledazzle on Monday January 11, 2016 @04:58AM (#10879878)
I'm honestly not sure how that's a personal attack (and I'm very much open to understanding your interpretation) but I definitely should have addressed it directly to you and for that I apologize.

That said, I do stand by the observation. Nitpicking small details that are unimportant to the overall point serves no one well and results in a waste of everyone's time.

Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Tuesday January 12, 2016 @12:46AM (#10885774)
Well, unfortunately your comment is gone now (I did not ask for it to be removed, nor did I 'flag' it [I can't]). If you repost it I could give a better analysis, but basically you were stating that I didn't "learn" anything.

1) You do not know what I "learn" or do not "learn" from any particular thing.

2) You do not know what lesson was being taught (or even if one was trying to be taught).

Your consideration that some things are "small details that are unimportant" is purely your consideration. While you may not see the importance of such details, others might. In this case, I think it is important that words actually have meaning and that if some words do not have an apparent logical meaning it should be explored more to come up with words that do have an apparent logical meaning (particularly when words, on their face, are self-contradictory).

Or, at least, it should be explored more what the author actually meant, or, might have meant to write in stead.

Re:How to fend off a jerk by brazzledazzle on Tuesday January 12, 2016 @04:32PM (#10890549)
This is specifically what I said:

"I guess jsprogrammer didn't learn much from their comments in that thread either."

I don't think that would change anything you said but please feel free to add to to it if needed.

Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Friday January 08, 2016 @03:32PM (#10867993)
I'm not sure sympathy is quite the right word either. Pitying someone is not very productive; I typically find it quite patronizing.
Re:How to fend off a jerk by dsp1234 on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:21PM (#10868376)
'Pity and sorrow' is one of the definitions of the word sympathy, but that's not the meaning generally implied when used in comparison to empathy.

"Sympathy (from the Greek words syn "together" and pathos "feeling" which means "fellow-feeling") is the perception, understanding, and reaction to the distress or need of another human being."[0]

"When you sympathize with someone, you have compassion for that person, but you don’t necessarily feel her feelings."[1]

Generally the difference between empathy and sympathy is the internal response to the feelings of others. If you personally are feeling the same thing as the person, then that's generally empathy, otherwise it's generally sympathy.

[0] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sympathy

[1] - http://grammarist.com/usage/empathy-sympathy/

Re:How to fend off a jerk by jsprogrammer on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:53PM (#10868597)

    define pity

    pit·y
    ˈpidē/
    noun
    noun: pity
    1.
    the feeling of sorrow and compassion caused by the suffering and misfortunes of others.

ok...downmods it is