Yes, 1.0 is stable and the language will not change in backwards incompatible ways. It's been that way for months (google "rust stability deliverable").
"All bugs fixed" rules out every language in existence except CompCert, so I don't think that's a very interesting metric.
Re:Why I love Rust
by nickpsecurity on Friday January 08, 2016 @01:16PM
(#10866913)
Good to know on stability part. Far as bugs fixed, it's more on the lines of day-to-day use of the language in common scenarios. Are people getting unnecessary troubles out of the compiler? Typically don't for most languages as they work out most of them in common idioms and library functions in first, few years. If they're serious rather than 1-3 people's hobby, that is.
I certainly won't expect it to be bug free. Nice comeback with CompCert, though. ;)
I've seen rust compiler bug once and that was long before 1.0. The only issue now is that some important API's are not yet declared stable (RFC still being open), so many 3rd-party libraries target nightly and won't work in stable. This is however matter or 1 or 2 releases, and proves that rust developers take this matter seriously and don't wont to stabilize anything they aren't 100% sure.
For all practical purposes rust is usable now, and more and more people are using it - certainly more then 3. Generally looking at rust projects on github,
most of issues are feature requests. I don't see issues with crashes or panics,
while I know plenty for similar projects written in C, at least in their early days.
Re:Why I love Rust
by nickpsecurity on Friday January 08, 2016 @04:38PM
(#10868499)
Thanks for the detailed assessment. Sounds like a high quality, Beta to me. I also like the good things I keep hearing about the quality of libraries, etc.
Back to beta-phase claim, you're saying the core features and compiler of Rust are no longer in development or testing? Totally stable now with only extensions, library features, and optimizations being added? If so, that's good news and I'll drop that claim in the future. Otherwise, it's in the beta phase. Another hint would be existence of any bugs with core functionality in your compiler or libraries.
Again, though, if the spec and core functionality are frozen with all bugs fixed then I won't call it beta. Is it there yet?