Re:An open letter to Paul Graham
by mattgibson on Friday January 08, 2016 @11:26AM
(#10865997)
I think the 80% thing you're discussing is a bit like the 'duplo economy' that PG mentions in his essay. Very large broad-brush taxation, with little specificity.
It would be trivial to make the taxation regime more high-resolution so that people who reinvest their cash into other ventures are taxed at a far lower rate, whereas those who wish to retire early and do nothing else are taxed a lot more.
Better to start from the society you want to see and work backwards from there to design a taxation system, rather that say yes or no to one or two one-size-fits-all options, I think.
Re:An open letter to Paul Graham
by pc86 on Friday January 08, 2016 @11:47AM
(#10866190)
If you reinvest money in a company, it's no longer your income, your AGI decreases, and your marginal and absolute tax rates both decrease. The current system is exactly as you describe.
It would be trivial to make the taxation regime more high-resolution so that people who reinvest their cash into other ventures are taxed at a far lower rate, whereas those who wish to retire early and do nothing else are taxed a lot more.
Better to start from the society you want to see and work backwards from there to design a taxation system, rather that say yes or no to one or two one-size-fits-all options, I think.