This arbitrage shows that only crediting wholesale prices is the wrong price.
Effectively, they're deleting load from close to the end user from the utility's books. If that load hadn't been deleted, the utility would have charged retail pricing in order to generate it.
The small negative adjustment from retail would come from the fact that the utility is still servicing the solar user as a retail user. So still needs to charge a set amount for admin costs & transmission (NOT generation) infrastructure.
Paying them wholesale is pretty ridiculous, and is a blatant abuse of the fact that they're a monopoly enshrined in law. If the state decides that you can't sell your electricity to anyone else because they anoint a utility, then that utility should absolutely be banned from exploiting that position to compensate solar generation less than it could.
If utilities can't balance their long-term amortizations of recent/new plants, then the state government can step in an reimburse them over the top for the disruption.
Sure but they would have only paid to wholesale rate to generate the power.
It's like going to the gas station and trying to sell them gasoline at their retail price. Why would they do that when they buy it at a cheaper price from someone else.
Remember that capacity is sized for peak utilization: the gap between average load and peak is load is extremely expensive, as it's by definition low-utilization compared to base load generation.
It also doesn't make a lot of sense to me that they charge higher fees to connect to the grid.
Definitely seems like a big win, short term, for the power companies. It seems like a big lose for renewables. Everyone seems to focused on whether it's perfectly fair or not - whereas I would say the goal of getting to environmentally friendly energy must weigh into the discuss - but hey, that's me.
Side note: I would be curious how much grid maintenance costs the power companies relative to their other costs.