I'd disagree that that depiction was better designed than http://www.dannyquah.com/Quilled/Output/2010.09.27-Danny.Qua... or the animation http://www.dannyquah.com/Quilled/Output/2010.08-Danny.Quah-w... It depends on what you're trying to understand. For what you describe, I personally don't like so much the McKinsey graphic. This is discussed in Section 8.3 (in Chapter 8) of my draft manuscript http://bit.ly/1KeSicU on Ordering the World.
But as a feedback
- What are the two extremes? I don't know the end points in your graphic.
- You graphic does not show how the center shifted from the East to the west after the industrial revolution. Because from 1500 to 2010 you actually have either hard data or past estimates.
- I would have put the distance of the dots (years) and a color legend in the picture.
- I am to stupid to understand what the different sized arrows mean in the graphic. What information do they provide?
Actually, the picture was similar (but better designed) to this one: https://dannyquah.wordpress.com/2012/05/17/how-we-miss-the-g...