I made about $1300/month as a PhD student at the end of the 90s/early 00s. But in exchange, I got to do the research I wanted to, it was a fair exchange for me. If you are in it just for the money, I guess it doesn't make much sense, but then you don't need a PhD anyways. I'm also one of the odd balls who is an American CS PhD graduate working for an American company in...China. Turns out, those high-end research jobs really can move from the US to another country (before China, I was in Switzerland)!
CS grads already easily make the most money out of all STEM graduates except maybe medicine which requires a much larger time/money investment.
Where exactly do you see the extra supply coming from if, say, CS wages went up another 50%? Who would be incentivized to study CS who isn't already sufficiently incentivized today?
The average CS PhD is what? 36k/yr? That is only attractive to international students who place a lot of value in being on US soil. The smart domestic students will avoid PhD programs and CS altogether, which is precisely what the industry wants, the self full filling prophecy of the "talent shortage".