News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The man who studies the spread of ignorance by tremon on Thursday January 07, 2016 @08:42AM (#10857805)
I particularly like the Swiss solution: employ topical referenda, and stop insisting that "everyone should vote". I'd rather have 60% of the people abstaining to vote because they don't care or don't know, than having them "sell" their vote to the lowest bidder with the nicest tie.

Especially for a "master of puppets"/figurehead election like POTUS, the problem isn't "too many uninformed people", it's "too many topics in a single vote". Even assuming 90% of your voters are knowledgeable about 90% of the issues, they can't express any of their knowledge in that single button or pencil stroke.

The same is true for trying to "divine" meaning to the votes cast, as well: since every voter only expressed a single button press, it's easy to dismiss votes that don't align with your own views as uninformed.

You want elections with depth? Don't make voting mandatory (either socially or legally), and use topical voting instead of figurehead voting.

Re:The man who studies the spread of ignorance by laotzu on Thursday January 07, 2016 @09:41AM (#10858122)
>use topical voting instead of figurehead voting.

This is entirely feasible now with the internet. One of the primary assumptions which led to to the design of a representative republic which we have on paper was that it was impossible for everyone to assemble in order to vote on laws:

>In a large society, inhabiting an extensive country, it is impossible that the whole should assemble to make laws. The first necessary step, then, is to depute power from the many to a few of the most wise and good.

-John Adams, Thoughts on Government

Re:The man who studies the spread of ignorance by apozem on Thursday January 07, 2016 @02:10PM (#10859997)
This is not feasible with the internet. Digital voting is a very, very bad idea. The long and short of arguments against online voting is that we've had several hundred years to figure out all the ways to cheat with paper votes and not nearly enough time to secure a similar system online. People spend billions on each presidential election- an online vote would become a target impossible to secure.

http://www.ncpa.org/sub/dpd/index.php?Article_ID=24488

Re:The man who studies the spread of ignorance by laotzu on Friday January 08, 2016 @10:10AM (#10865345)
The argument that an electric system is not feasible because it cannot be made 100% secure is null and self defeating if at the same time it is implicitly in support of a legacy paper system which is already exploited and cannot be made 100% secure. A better argument would be a cost-benefit analysis of both systems instead of defaulting to hypocritical defeatism. Security risks will always be a given.

I would say, though, that it would not be feasible given the current state of internet architecture. Internet infrastructure would need to become much more universally distributed and control would need to be relinquished by the current "internet gatekeepers" (i.e. Time Warner, Comcast etc.) as Aaron Swartz called them.

There is also the irony that in the US and elsewhere, the paper system is actively exploited and used as a means to make the electric system more insecure i.e. weakening/backdooring encryption.

With any new system, there will be technical challenges and unknowns that will be sorted out(ish) after trial and error as was the case with the Articles of Confederation which failed but then lead to the current longest lasting constitutional government today.

Re:The man who studies the spread of ignorance by bpires on Thursday January 07, 2016 @09:54AM (#10858185)
Referendums don't really solve anything. Here are some of the questionable ones that have passed:

1.Minarets can no longer be built in Switzerland. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_minaret_referendum,_2009 2. Immigration quotas. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Swiss_immigration_referendum,_...

I'm not an european citizen, have a job offer to work in a big tech company in Zurich and will not be able to get a visa even though I've got my Bachelors and Masters degree in Europe. Since the referendum passed, they're now requiring 3 years full-time work experience regardless of which education degree you hold.

Re:The man who studies the spread of ignorance by rawTruthHurts on Thursday January 07, 2016 @10:26AM (#10858386)
Well, they're voting for their own Swiss issues, not even european (as in "EU european") issues. Political correctness aside, I don't think they're questionable.