News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Myth of AI – Jaron Lanier by stepvhen on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @01:48PM (#10852630)
Religion itself does a lot of hand waving, and people tend to talk about the "existential threat" of AI with a lot of hand waving. Its an easy comparison to make. Also, a claim, by itself, can't be a religion. It would need people to attach to it with a certain fervor.

>it doesn't distinguish between what AI can do right now, and what the theoretical limit of AI is, in 50 or 100 or 500 years.

AI, by itself, cannot interact with the physical world, past bit-flipping registers on a cpu (a negligible action). For AI to be a threat, in my opinion, it would need to be coupled with some form of physical manifestation that could, in some fashion, not be under the control of a human. Until that happens, we can just unplug the machine. And we are already seeing the intense difficulty of robotics, making good robots, and interfacing with the real world. Historically, everything with AI is much, much harder than originally thought.

Re:The Myth of AI – Jaron Lanier by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:47PM (#10853159)
There's a pretty cool story about underestimating bit-flipping :).

http://lesswrong.com/lw/qk/that_alien_message/

Besides, just look at us, humans. Who would ever build an AI and then keep it away from any means of communication? That wouldn't be a very useful AI. If one wants that, one can pick a rock and imagine it has a mind. Or talk to a cat.

Re:The Myth of AI – Jaron Lanier by stepvhen on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @04:07PM (#10853776)
That was a fun read.
Re:The Myth of AI – Jaron Lanier by pjc50 on Thursday January 07, 2016 @05:27AM (#10857142)
we can just unplug the machine

A look at the history of managing downsides of industrial technology tells us that we can't or won't "unplug" it if it's still profitable or an integral part of a vital system. Carbon dioxide changing the climate and acidifying the oceans? Unplug the coal-fired power stations! Overuse of antibiotics, especially in animals, leading to deaths in humans? How about we don't do that!

The first "hostile" AI will only be selectively hostile. Perhaps something like automated "redlining" racial discrimination. Some sort of system where the benefits accrue to investors while the disadvantages are spread around. AI "pollution".

Re:The Myth of AI – Jaron Lanier by pixl97 on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:03PM (#10853279)
>AI, by itself, cannot interact with the physical world, past bit-flipping registers on a cpu (a negligible action). For AI to be a threat, in my opinion, it would need to be coupled with some form of physical manifestation that could, in some fashion, not be under the control of a human.

Now that's just silly.

An AI does not need a body for any reason. What it needs is a voice, software is pretty good at simulating that, and we can simulate images and video pretty well too. If an AI can become a master in the art of persuasion (say coupled with a great hacking ability) it could easily convince people to act in its name (much like old books do now) and pay off others do to its bidding.

Re:The Myth of AI – Jaron Lanier by TeMPOraL on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:22PM (#10853443)
Indeed. On the Internet, nobody knows that the person ordering and paying for your services is in fact a superintelligent AI :).
Re:The Myth of AI – Jaron Lanier by drakenot on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @02:01PM (#10852729)
I wouldn't underestimate the effects that just bit-flipping registers on a cpu can have, even today. In the future, with increased automation, the effects of controlling those bits will be even more severe.