Re:The Myth of AI – Jaron Lanier
by randallsquared on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @12:40PM
(#10852002)
I'm a little confused. We have self-driving cars. Of course there are still corner cases and bugs and regulatory issues, but cars have driven for fair distances on existing roads without a human driving. I had assumed, therefore, that the point @VLM was making was that, like self-driving cars, we already have AI by many of the standards of earlier AI researchers (the "when it works, it's not called AI any longer" argument).
I was reading "self-driving cars" as "Level 4 autonomy" under general conditions. Which IMO is many decades away.
But we're in violent agreement about the "when it works, it's not called AI any longer" argument.
Like many other aspects of AI, I'm not sure just about anyone thinks we need to have strong AI to make self-driving cars work under the vast majority of conditions. We "just" need to create automation that can handle a reasonable number of corner cases without flipping out or grinding to a halt. But that's a debate about engineering timelines not something more philosophical.