News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by brudgers on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:18PM (#10846930)
Bitcoin is one protocol that establishes trust between two parties for an arms length transaction. That it uses cryptographic hashing is an implementation detail to the same degree that pieces of paper are an implementation detail of Wells Fargo money orders. What matters is that one person can reliably pay another person. The fact that people speculate on Bitcoin and not on Wells Fargo money orders should not cloud our thinking.

The Bitcoin protocol strives for absolute consistency to mitigate risk. Other cryptographic hash based protocols that are described as "blockchains" may trade the overhead of absolute consistency for speed and lower computational overhead, e.g. Ripple [1] uses consensus between `n - c*n` nodes as the basis of trust along with transaction costs to mitigate the odds of Byzantine failure that would result in double spend; in exchange transactions execute more rapidly and with less computational overhead. Again, there's nothing magical about the implementation details. What matters is reliable trusted transactions of value. Bitcoin transfers can happen on the order of minutes, Ripple transactions can happen on the order of seconds.

What technologies that are described as "blockchains" tend to provide is low transaction fees. The time and expense of moving value via blockchain from Berlin to Cartagena is low compared to wire transfer independent of the blockchain's provenance...provided of course that the end units of the exchange are suitable to all parties. There's nothing magical beyond it being easier than using goats as the medium of exchange.

[1]: https://ripple.com/

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by XorNot on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:25PM (#10846990)
People seem to vastly over-estimate the time and expense of moving money internationally. It is not difficult, nor expensive at the moment. Bitcoin has very poor liquidity and enormous volatility compared to regular currencies at scale.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by brudgers on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:43PM (#10847103)
Volatility doesn't matter much if Bitcoin is just a medium for transferring value within a transaction in normal business circumstances, i.e. slight fluctuations in exchange rates over the course of an hour can be built into the offer. Forex style arbitrage and speculative investments are of course another matter...one in which Bitcoin is no different from other currencies.

The liquidity constraints of Bitcoin may ultimately limit its general adoption and perhaps encourages speculation over use. And is why, despite my lack of clarity, I did not intend to suggest that Bitcoin was better than Wells Fargo money orders for moving money internationally. That doesn't mean that blockchains may not prove to be significantly better.

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by erikpukinskis on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @10:21PM (#10848236)
I agree liquidity is a weakness.

However it's a classic disruptive technology scenario. Bitcoin is weaker than other currencies in almost every way, but it has its few very special advantages.

For now the only users are people for whom those advantages are paramount. That small group of dedicated users will use it dedicatedly and slowly the ecosystem builds up around it until other limitations are mitigated.

At that point we'll need to reassess its competitiveness.