News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kang on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @02:46PM (#10845493)
> or some transactions could be moved to “sidechains” as proposed in systems like the Bitcoin Lightning Network. But the Lightning Network is useful only for a ledger that is denominated in Bitcoin, and we still have to deal with the “central” Bitcoin blockchain, whose size is likely to continue to increase despite the addition of various “sidechain” mechanisms.

This is incorrect for multiple reasons.

> "Takes over 10 minutes to “commit” a transaction"

Incorrect. Average wait time would be less than 5 minutes.

> "Turning your Bitcoins into cold hard cash denominated in the currency of your choice is perhaps the cryptocurrency’s biggest problem"

It is author's world view based on pre-bitcoin times that cold hard cash is better. It can be said that turning cash to bitcoins is fiat's biggest problem.

>"moving money between ledgers actually involves integrating with those ugly legacy systems"

Assets on different blockchains can be swapped using various methods and does not need third parties.

> "there are far more efficient distributed consensus algorithms than this which don’t involve a proof of work."

Author gives the example of Interledger and SCP. Without proof-of-work origin of money will always be controversial. Both Ripple and SCP create money out of thin air.

>a very cool feature I will acknowledge exists and give a quick hat tip to Ethereum

There is NOTHING that ethereum can do that you can't do with bitcoin.

> Bitcoin-NG (paper), a protocol that inverts the ordering of Bitcoin consensus: a miner is first elected leader by winning the proof-of-work “lottery” by mining a “key block”, and then once elected leader becomes a transaction broker who can mint “micro-blocks” via digital signature until the next leader is elected.

Many problems linked https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3or365/bitcoinng_p...

I did not read last 3 paras. The author is damn right that Blockchains are world's shittiest databases and should not be used so.

In my personal understanding of what blockchain is, the author didn't mention it as a DMMS(Dynamic membership multiparty signature). This has been explained in the sidechains whitepaper, which most people do not read due to another myth that the employees of a private company 'blockstream' are majority of Bitcoin Core devs. Anyone trying to understand the blockchain should read the introduction of that paper. https://www.blockstream.com/sidechains.pdf

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by geofft on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @03:18PM (#10845704)
> Both Ripple and SCP create money out of thin air.

So does fiat, and fiat works. It may not work well all the time for 100% of use cases, but in general it works well.

As long as the mechanisms by which money is created out of thin air are well-understood by the people receiving this money (which they are for fiat) and the recipients give informed consent to that (which they... sorta do for fiat), this doesn't seem like a negative.

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by XorNot on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:28PM (#10846999)
Fiat money works because governments pay for services in it, and demand taxes in it.

If you are not a government, fiat money does not work for you.*

* Quasi-government entities have a long history of issuing currency like this - company scrip was one such practice, but its important to note that this is a situation of a company becoming more government-like.

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by geofft on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:33PM (#10847041)
I'm a little confused, I think I paid for groceries last night in fiat currency and I certainly got goods in exchange for them, and I don't believe the grocery store was run by the government. Can you clarify what you mean by "does not work for you"? I suspect we mean different things by the phrase.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by XorNot on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:44PM (#10847109)
The general "you". You (some entity) can't issue your own fiat currency successfully unless you are sufficiently government-like.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by geofft on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:55PM (#10847172)
Sure, but a) I have no interest in issuing Bitcoin or any other currency, just using it as long as it works, and b) if I were to issue an altcoin, I would be creating money out of thin air!
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by bduerst on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @04:23PM (#10846161)
Precisely - most major currencies today ditched their deflationary practices in the 20th century.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kang on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @05:29PM (#10846580)
So does paypal. I was comparing decentralized currencies.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by geofft on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @07:07PM (#10847246)
But why is creating money out of thin air bad, regardless of whether a currency is centralized or decentralized? (Other than that it sounds scary.)
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by tveita on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @02:59PM (#10845588)
> Incorrect. Average wait time would be less than 5 minutes.

Average wait time for a block is around 10 minutes. You may be thinking of it in terms of buses, where if there is a bus every 10th minute, you'd expect a 5 minute average wait. But blocks are mined practically independently, you could get two in a minute, or none in an hour. Turns out, no matter when you start waiting for a block, the average waiting time will be 10 minutes.

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kang on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @05:01PM (#10846403)
Two in a minute or one in hour averages out to 10; the difficulty adjusts itself to do so.

However, I said "less than" 5 because difficulty has been increasing and more blocks are less than 10 minutes than not.

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by bduerst on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @05:21PM (#10846522)
While the difficulty is scaling it comes out to about seven and a half minutes per block, not five or below five.

https://blockchain.info/charts/avg-confirmation-time?show_he...

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kang on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @05:51PM (#10846730)
Interesting. Roughly 3,682,674 minutes have passed since its inception so expected blocks would be 368,267 whereas it is 391,933. Thus average should be less than 5. I guess due to low frequency of transactions the median is not the same as average.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kanzure on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @02:53PM (#10845544)
> > Bitcoin-NG

> Many problems linked https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3or365/bitcoinng_p...

Thanks dude, I forgot about my comment there. As for weak blocks, how about this one:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/3m2wpf/bitcoindev_...

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by miscellaneous on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @05:38PM (#10846646)
> There is NOTHING that ethereum can do that you can't do with bitcoin.

That is factually incorrect. Bitcoin is not turing complete, Ethereum is. Eg: You can't do loops in Bitcoin, you can in Ethereum.

Perhaps you are speculating about the potential capabilities of sidechains, but they isn't a reality at the present.

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kang on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @05:59PM (#10846788)
'Do with' not 'do in'. For example, there could be an ether-tcp that transports data using unused header bytes. Now factually you don't send data 'in' TCP header so TCP-ether might seem better, but actually you can send data 'with' TCP and thus TCP-ether is redundant.

Think of any Ethereum usecase and you can do it with bitcoin.

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by ItsMattyG on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @03:12AM (#10849261)
>Think of any Ethereum usecase and you can do it with bitcoin.

Yes, but it's a lot harder. Look at for instance the colored coins project vs. implementing a custom token on ethereum.

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by aakilfernandes on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:03PM (#10846824)
x of 1,000 multisig, where each signature is controlled by a tradable token
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kang on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:52PM (#10847162)
Schnorr Signatures plus Colored coins
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by wolfgke on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @07:09PM (#10847251)
Aren't these extensions to the Bitcoin protocol (rather than core of it)? This question is curious interest, not a counterargument to yours.
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kang on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @07:44PM (#10847415)
Voice can be transmitted as packets using IP, but is VOIP an extension of IP or core use of it? Well, I guess we can call it either, because the end result is similar (but the side-effects are not).
Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by aakilfernandes on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @07:34PM (#10847359)
I am under the impression that colored coins can't be used as inputs in a multisig.

Also, can you expand on Schnorr Signatures

Re:On the dangers of a blockchain monoculture by kang on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @07:50PM (#10847456)
They can be, depends on how they have been colored. 1-of-4,294,967,296 multisig is doable in bitcoin theoretically using Schnorr signatures https://blockstream.com/2015/08/24/treesignatures/