Re:Income inequality is not the problem, it's a symptom
by AnthonyMouse on Thursday January 07, 2016 @09:52AM
(#10858179)
> assuming the patent is valid, Monstanto had morally won the case.
That was my point. The process is designed so that any case where that is not the predictable outcome will be settled and put under NDA so nobody can know about it. The process that results in that consequence is the despicable act, and is what causes the intimidation, because it allows them to claim having won every case etc.
Reading the Monsanto vs Schmeiser case, however, it seems pretty clear that Schmeiser infringed the patent (he intentionally used it without having the legal right to do so); we can argue (and probably agree) whether patenting of genes should be allowed or not, but assuming the patent is valid, Monstanto had morally won the case.