But that doesn't mean there's no solution for tracing calls. It needs just one extra law for telcos to solve most of this issue: "Either you can prove/point to the interconnect which originated this call, or you take full responsibility for this call and its contents." Then law enforcement can just continue to the next company and the next until they get to the subscriber.
Two answers to questions I expect: - What about international numbers? If you get a call from Russia claiming it's IRS, that's really not plausible - that can be understood by everyone. If telco gets a call from Russia with US callerid, then again, its their responsibility to only choose partners which they can query to check if that's valid. (it's not a huge barrier - telcos are already aware of various international issues)
- This will require registration of all subscribers with real details, what about privacy? Yes, yes it will.
Whether or not a call with domestic looking CPN from an international location will be accepted is up to the switches handling it, but they're designed to successfully complete a call in almost any possible circumstance. It's possible that the international gateway might rewrite the CPN field with something else, but I doubt they'd go as far as refusing to let it through.
The screen parameter within SS7 details whether or not the CPN field has been defined by the end user. Most SIP users won't have access to this either, but the vast majority of calls from them (but not from other sources) will look like the number is user provided. For that reason, some voicemail systems that've historically let you log in automatically just by setting your CPN to the subscriber number have started to only let you do that when the screen parameter is set to network provided.