News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wi-Fi Alliance introduces low power, long range Wi-Fi HaLow by bsder on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:31PM (#10840924)
I'd be happy if they just spec'd a 2mW WiFi, thanks. The fact that I can see my neighbor's WiFi is actually a hindrance, not a benefit, nowadays.
Re:Wi-Fi Alliance introduces low power, long range Wi-Fi HaLow by xorcist on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @04:54AM (#10842361)
Output power is a setting in your wireless driver. Just set it to whatever is appropriate. (Getting your neighbor onboard is probably the bigger challenge.) Getting the power just right is a big part of planning large scale wifi installations. You could also put dampening (basically a resistor-like thing) in line with your antenna.

There's been several proposals how to do this automatically, which would do a lot for the congestion problem you mention, for the IEEE standardization process. But I have no idea if they made it into the newer standards. Unless you actively cooperate with your neighbors, it turns into a tragedy of the commons. The one with the power regulating equipment will have worse performance to start with, but if everyone has it then everyone benefits.

Re:Wi-Fi Alliance introduces low power, long range Wi-Fi HaLow by Gibbon1 on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:51PM (#10841011)
I'm somewhat concerned about LoRa and things like it for that reason. Having a transmitter emitting energy in your band is bad. But having a bunch of transmitters emitting coherent energy you're receiver can detect it worse. The former just cuts down your signal to noise. The latter directly limits your available bandwidth. Which is to say, if your radio detects the beginning of a weak packet from far away it's locked down for the duration. Can't transmit, can't receive another stronger packet that arrives slightly later.
Re:Wi-Fi Alliance introduces low power, long range Wi-Fi HaLow by hodwik2 on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:15PM (#10841151)
LoraWan is inherently monolithic. There is only supposed to be one LoraWan provider, who acts as the router, and passes traffic to receiver according to their address -- just like a cell tower. You don't have a hundred cell towers, you have 3.
Re:Wi-Fi Alliance introduces low power, long range Wi-Fi HaLow by yaantc on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @06:51AM (#10842721)
Not so. Sigfox has a single operator model: they're the only operator for their proprietary technology. But LoRa is multi-operator: anyone can buy LoRa base station and deploy their network (it's in unlicensed spectrum). And it's already happening this way. So several operators and even technologies will share the same limited unlicensed spectrum. Should be interesting when it scales...
Re:Wi-Fi Alliance introduces low power, long range Wi-Fi HaLow by stevegriff on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @11:05AM (#10843913)
It was designed to be "single operator", but that's not how it is shaking out. I think a trainwreck is coming, because if you have multiple LoRaWAN networks operating in the same area, all the packets are colliding at layer 2. They have to be thrown away by the server. And since the Semtech SX1301 baseband chip only has 8 demodulators, capacity quickly approaches zero, if there are multiple uncoordinated networks.

LoRaWAN is an okay solution for European Carrier networks where duty cycle limitations come into pay, but for the 915MHz band, it is not a good design.

Re:Wi-Fi Alliance introduces low power, long range Wi-Fi HaLow by smt88 on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:39PM (#10840963)
Increasing WiFi range doesn't mean much for most consumers, but it's hugely important for deploying WiFi to large public spaces (city streets, offices, parks, etc.)

(On an unrelated note, the fact that you can see your neighbor's WiFi seems like one of the smallest imaginable hindrances and a terrible reason to reconsider WiFi innovation goals.)