News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by HSO on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:11PM (#10840816)
> But economic inequality per se is not bad.

Both essays feel like they are built on a strawman argument. Nobody serious said inequality was bad or good, not even Piketty. The discussion is about degrees, and PG adds nothing to it by arguing categorically.

That we are talking degrees of inequality is also the reason why economists argue with statistics and do not differentiate much between specific causes or mechanisms on the micro level. Sorry to burst that bubble but PG is not a "creator of inequality" on the level that is interesting. Shifting a few hundred people around means nothing given that we are talking about income and wealth distributions over millions of households in the US alone (and increasing inequality is a global phenomenon). Clearly, tax policy, financial (de)regulation, labor market policies, even the fall of the Soviet Union, etc. are more relevant than petty arguments over whether this startup or that high freq trader made a few mega- or even gigabucks in a nice or not so nice way.

On a sidenote, the relative impacts of the trader vs the startupper on aggregate welfare is not as clearcut as intimated by PG at all, once you take second- and higher-order effects into account. Furthermore, creating wealth for some individuals may also decrease overall inequality; it depends on the starting and end positions of said individuals in the wealth distribution and the other ongoing processes in the economy.

Lastly, economic systems have a lot of feedback mechanisms, both positive (ie destabilizing) and negative (stabilizing). We should at least consider the possibility that past a certain degree of inequality, wealth becomes self-perpetuating. This is especially pertinent for US Americans, given the degenerate nature of their "democracy".

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by dools on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:29PM (#10840914)
Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by vasilipupkin on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:36PM (#10840949)
The issue is not static levels of inequality per se. The issue is why inequality should increase. If the 60%th percentile incomes grew 40%, then it is not clear why the bottom 20% percentile income also shouldn't grow 40%. The fact that it didn't is suboptimal and studying this phenomenon makes sense. That doesn't mean that every knee jerk attempt to fix this problem is good.

Let me try to explain it like this. It is a valid question to ask why, if one income bracket grew X% over 20 years, did a lower bracket only grow 1/2 X. It is not reasonable to simply dismiss this question as irrelevant by assumption. Because society should want income to grow in all brackets, if possible

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by dools on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:42PM (#10840980)
There is an acceptable level of income inequality, the same as there is an acceptable level of inflation. The determination of what that level of income inequality is, is a complex social analysis task. It's somewhat arbitrary (for example we currently view 3% as an acceptable level of inflation, but that could well be 10% if we wanted it to and we could still make society work). There isn't a single level of income inequality that is bad in all situations, but for some given set of social conditions there exists a level of income inequality that is bad (even if we can't determine precisely what it is ... )
Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by vasilipupkin on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:48PM (#10840999)
right. But we are observing both large differences in income growth for bottom brackets vs middle and top brackets AND slow growth in bottom income. And there are economic models that show that these two phenomena are not independent. So, this is something that deserves to be researched, not dismissed and has very little to do with startups, unlike what PG is talking about
Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by chrispeel on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @12:19AM (#10848771)
this.

And the question is how do we get to that acceptable level. One option is a progressive income tax with a universal basic income, or (equivalently) having the progressive income turn negative at low incomes.

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by dools on Wednesday January 06, 2016 @06:27AM (#10849914)
I'm more of the opinion that a broad based consumption tax with offsets given to people on a sliding scale would be more effective (after all, people are way less likely to refuse money than they are to try and get out of paying it ... ) This would cause a (once off) inflationary bump as wages adjusted to the price increase but this could be contained with effective fiscal policy.

Taxing consumption makes more sense since ideally we want less of it, but taxing income makes less sense because we want people to work more.

I like Randall Wray's idea of taxing the volume of people's houses, too[1] :) He also talks about abolishing all company and payroll taxes, because as soon as you let go of the notion that taxes pay for things, and that the role of taxation is actually to drive demand for currency and control aggregate demand/income inequality, your fiscal policy can get pretty wild.

It's funny how MMT can seem quite "conservative" at times because of things like abolishing company tax, but when you accept the basic tenets of MMT you can see that such things can be quite progressive (and good for society)!

[1] http://neweconomicperspectives.org/2014/06/tax-bads-goods.ht...

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by dawnbreez on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @02:21PM (#10845316)
If possible, yes. But, barring a technological change that affects every single field of work in such a way that everyone is making more money, it is impossible.
Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by HSO on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:45PM (#10840991)
From skimming the links provided, my impression is that these authors or texts address increases in inequality or the importance of the middle class (which presumes inequality). Can you show more directly where someone is arguing for/against inequality per se (as opposed to an argument about the proper degree of inequality)?
Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by dools on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:54PM (#10841029)
There is a proper degree of inequality -- too much central planning or regulation to produce complete equality stifles innovation and leads to all sorts of problems. Too much inequality and deregulation leads to instability.

When people talk about income inequality being bad, they're talking about bad income inequality, not acceptable income inequality.

So things that increase income inequality in such a way that it is unchecked or unregulated are bad, and income inequality needs to be controlled directly through regulation and taxation, and directly through increased government spending and full employment.

When PG says "income inequality isn't bad per se" I take it to mean that he sees the current level of income inequality, for example, in the US, as not bad, which is incorrect. The levels of income inequality in the US are causing problems with stability in the economy. He also doesn't see a problem with increasing the current levels of inequality in income in the US.

If he means that some level of inequality of income is acceptable then he's not being very clear about it.

Just as some level of inflation is acceptable, some level of lead and arsenic in drinking water, and some level of sugar consumption is acceptable, so too is some level of income inequality acceptable.

EDIT: changed "inequality" to "equality" in first line ...

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by HSO on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:05PM (#10841104)
> When PG says "income inequality isn't bad per se" I take it to mean that he sees the current level of income inequality, for example, in the US, as not bad,

Well, then you are more generous than I am. To me, it is a classic strawman and leads the whole essay astray. But I see then we do not disagree. I thought you were trying to support the strawman with your links.

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by Tycho on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:30PM (#10840921)
The way the phrase is thrown about is unmistakably negative IMO.

For a start, 'inequality' is a phrase borrowed from far clearer grievances such as inequality in legal rights for women, minorities etc. By using it in this economic debate it already frames the question as one of harm to a group of people.

A neutral phrase would be something like 'wealth concentration.'

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by viraptor on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:47PM (#10840996)
> Nobody serious said inequality was bad or good, not even Piketty.

From the Capital ...:

> Inequality is not necessarily bad in itself: the key question is to decide whether it is justified, whether there are reasons for it.

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by spikels on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:37PM (#10841223)
He is not arguing "categorically". You are simply misunderstanding. No strawman. Sorry.
Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by HSO on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @12:02AM (#10841324)
Let me quote from http://www.paulgraham.com/ineq.html:

> when I hear people saying that economic inequality is bad and should be eliminated, I feel rather like a wild animal overhearing a conversation between hunters.

Nobody is arguing "inequality is bad and should be eliminated". People are arguing that inequality has increased too much and should be dialed back. The question is how (and what is a more reasonable level).

> I'm all for shutting down the crooked ways to get rich. But that won't eliminate economic inequality,

Ditto

> And while it would probably be a good thing for the world if people who wanted to get rich switched from playing zero-sum games to creating wealth, that would not only not eliminate economic inequality,

Ditto

> You can't end economic inequality without preventing people from getting rich, and you can't do that without preventing them from starting startups.

The policy debate is not and never was about "ending inequality". It is to find a different level. And the precise reason people are not advocating for "eliminating inequality" is incentives.

As you can see: Strawman. Strawman. Strawman. All the way. Sorry.

Re:Economic Inequality: The Simplified Version by vasilipupkin on Tuesday January 05, 2016 @12:43PM (#10844666)
Yes, definitely a strawman. I am not aware of any mainstream politicians or economists proposing to eliminate inequality. Perhaps you can find an anarchist or a communist or two who are proposing that, but it's not on any agenda that has any policy relevance.