News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:28AM (#1084009)
It's the new subscription model, subscribe to rights that you should have by default. Such as the ability to program the computer that you just bought.

Early computers all came with built in programming capability, then we lost some of that and then open source happened and suddenly it seemed ridiculous to ask developers money to support your platform.

It's like charging the guys that sweep your street toll.

Be happy that people want to develop for your platform and make it as easy as possible for them.

Things like this will incrementally push developers away from closed platforms. Why on earth would anybody pay a subscription to a toolchain. Open source tools are abundant and free, run on practically any piece of hardware from small embedded controllers all the way to supercomputers.

When switching from a windows environment to open source for my main dev box a couple of years ago, I was worried about not being able to bring my tools along. Now I feel completely unable to do anything useful on a machine that does not come with at least a full complement of unix tools.

I can see a device like the ipad as a target, but if development is going to be limited to apple-only then the subscription fee is the smaller part (we do have an imac here, but I doubt that everybody that wants to develop for the pad has a mac ready to go).

So for some the cost is significantly higher than just the subscription to the SDK.

I prefer software without a built in expiry date anyway.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by cpr on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:50AM (#1084082)
The apps you built will never expire. (I know that from personal experience; we let our iPhone dev certificate expire for a while due to lack of attention, but our apps never failed to work.)

The SDK you've downloaded will never expire.

Yes, the ability to sign apps will disappear, but you could run them in unsigned debug mode forever.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:56AM (#1084096)
So, effectively you're on the hook for as long as you decide to support your product.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by cpr on Thursday January 28, 2010 @11:03AM (#1084120)
Sure thing! I don't find it offensive to pay $99/year to Apple in exchange for them maintaining their developer portal and tools.

They invest tens of millions in the toolchain alone every year, and, I'm even underwriting a lot of great LLVM/clang open source development with my fee...

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by wizard_2 on Thursday January 28, 2010 @11:33AM (#1084222)
They also take 30% of every app you sell. The fact I bought doodle jump underwrote the developer tools. As of this year they are the single biggest mobile company due to their app and phone sales. The $100 a developer isn't much of a profit for them as it is a means to control access.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by cpr on Thursday January 28, 2010 @12:41PM (#1084431)
I'm sorry, but I don't think 30% is an unreasonable cut.

When I sell my current indie Mac/Win software through resellers, I have to give them at least 25% to make it worth their while.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @01:15PM (#1084533)
> I'm sorry, but I don't think 30% is an unreasonable cut.

That's good for you. Did you negotiate with Apple?

Or did you find that since there can not be any competition that it was 30% or forget it?

> When I sell my current indie Mac/Win software through resellers, I have to give them at least 25% to make it worth their while.

Ah, but the interesting bit here is that apparently there you can negotiate.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by cpr on Thursday January 28, 2010 @04:42PM (#1085126)
Well, not really--if you don't give a reseller at least 20-25%, they're not going to be motivated to sell.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by wizard_2 on Thursday January 28, 2010 @03:42PM (#1084960)
Neither do I, I'm just saying it's making them very profitable, much more so then the developer fee. So much more that I don't see the developer fee as a source of income.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by GHFigs on Thursday January 28, 2010 @11:10AM (#1084143)
...rights that you should have by default. Such as the ability to program the computer that you just bought.

Do you feel this applies equally to everything that "computes" (including your cable box, your microwave, your car, your dumbphone etc.) or is there some threshold at which that expectation begins?

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @11:13AM (#1084152)
I draw the line at appliances that are 'single use' versus appliances that are dual-to-universal uses.

For instance the 'slug' is a nice example of such a device, it is far more useful 'open' than it ever was closed.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by wizard_2 on Thursday January 28, 2010 @11:27AM (#1084200)
Slug?
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by brandon on Thursday January 28, 2010 @12:06PM (#1084331)
I believe he means the Linksys NSLU NAS box.

The thing is, modding that device isn't much different from jailbreaking your iPhone. If you're okay with invalidating the warrantee on the slug, then I don't understand why you'd complain about the iPhone/Pad model since it's largely the same: Keep Out!

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by orangecat on Thursday January 28, 2010 @01:01PM (#1084491)
f you're okay with invalidating the warrantee on the slug, then I don't understand why you'd complain about the iPhone/Pad model

It's not a question of voiding the warranty; Apple is on record saying that jailbreaking is and should be a criminal act.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @01:12PM (#1084517)
> Apple is on record saying that jailbreaking is and should be a criminal act.

In case you haven't heard about that before:

http://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2009/02/apple-says-jailbreaking...

And let's make sure that it really sinks in what they are saying here:

If you buy a device you do not own it and can not do with it what pleases you.

And this from the manufacturer of a computer that was as open as it could possibly be, the Apple II.

Sometimes I find it hard to believe how far we've come and then at the same time how much we have lost.

Steve Jobs is an absolutely awesome business guy, the way he has turned Apple around will be studied for decades. At the same time I wonder if it would have been possible without all this nastiness. If not then more power to him, but I prefer to think of the other Steve when I look at Apple and what might have been.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by GHFigs on Thursday January 28, 2010 @01:50PM (#1084633)
I recommend reading the actual documents the EFF is reporting on before drawing conclusions. I did so months ago and I think the EFF's reporting on it is grossly misleading.

The context is Apple's response to the EFF's filing for a DMCA exemption for jailbreaking as part of the DMCA rulemaking process. In other words: it is already illegal if it involves a copyright violation, and the EFF was trying to get it made a special exemption. Exemptions are considered based on certain requirements in the law, and a number have been granted. What Apple actually said was that jailbreaking should not be specially exempted from the DMCA for the reasons the EFF cited, because they don't meet the requirements in the law. If you actually look at the reasons the EFF cited, I think you'll find that they don't.

Again, I recommend reading the filings yourself, and the law on DMCA exemptions, and the list of existing exemptions, and make up your own mind.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @02:03PM (#1084663)
Here is what apple actually said:

"Congress did not envision the DMCA exemption process as a forum for economic restructuring of business models... As this submission will demonstrate, the evidence shows that a business model in which handsets can be widely jailbroken with the attendant problems that result would in fact hinder the creation and distribution of creative works for the platform."

I figure next up is the suggestion that Apple strongly lobbied against the DMCA.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by GHFigs on Thursday January 28, 2010 @05:44PM (#1085282)
Congress did not envision the DMCA exemption process as a forum for economic restructuring of business models...

I double dog dare you to claim that the EFF was not attempting to abuse the DMCA exemption process to this end.

I figure next up is the suggestion that Apple strongly lobbied against the DMCA.

I have no idea what you're talking about.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @12:34PM (#1084410)
Absolutely, I was using the slug as an example of what hardware is capable of in the hands of competent programmers. The fact that you have to void the warranty or 'jailbreak' it is really sad.