That incentive sounds pretty terrible for the public. Great for insurance companies though.
Insurers are now limited to making 20% profit maximum under ACA to prevent pathological scenarios like that. Will there be a reduction in "innovation"? Maybe, but how much innovation do you need from a payment scheme? In any case, the game now is to increase their subscriber base by stealing from competitors or the uninsured, both likely to result in benefits to consumers.
I found this site helpful too:
The public is already required by law to pay the insurance companies. But with a fixed, lower fine, I suppose there's a "laffner curve", where insurance companies can't raise their prices too much or enough people will opt for the IRS penalty that the insurance market would stop having enough buy-in.
But it shouldn't be surprising that the IRS penalties (in current form) could not solve this. This eventuality was predicted before the law was passed in the Senate (e.g., [0]). It seems fairly obvious that this would happen unless fines are somehow pegged to the cheapest insurance rates (as dpweb notes in this same HN story[1]).
[0] https://reason.com/blog/2009/11/06/higher-premiums-less-cove...
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=dpweb