News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:10AM (#1083950)
> Think of the App Store as the public roads for the iPad--the state has a vested interest in making sure that drivers are minimally competent, so they have a gatekeeping function in the form of a license.

That really makes no sense at all. You are basically saying that in order to produce software you have to pass a 'driving test', but in fact there are millions of people producing open source software that would make the majority of these apps look like the toys they are.

Sorry, but that really doesn't fly with me, the app store is simply a method of control that has nothing to do with quality.

Or were those google programmers that got their application refused somehow incompetent?

The only arbiter of what is 'good enough' and what isn't is the user, not some approval process.

If all they did was scan for malware I'd have no problem with it.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by cpr on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:37AM (#1084042)
Ok, perhaps the analogy was weak.

Perhaps it's more like you're building cars for people to drive, and some third party needs to check before people get in the car and kill themselves because you've made a steering wheel that falls off under slight stress.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:41AM (#1084057)
Notepad computers don't kill people, worst case your stuff doesn't work and they won't use it again.

This is not 'mission critical' by a long shot.

It all boils down to the safety vs freedom argument, we can be 100% safe or we can have a lot of freedom. Personally I'll take the freedom, if you want to be 100% safe but only able to run vendor approved applications then that's fine with me, but it is one step too many in the direction of 'trusted computing' for me.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by cpr on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:47AM (#1084076)
No, worst case your app steals their credit card info (witness the recent Android bank phishing app) and costs them tremendous time and bother (not to say potentially money) cleaning up the mess.

In this case, at the first sign of malwareism, Apple can disable the app immediately for everyone, limiting the damage.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by jacquesm on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:52AM (#1084088)
Phishing requires active participation by the end user, you can't protect against stupidity.

Do app store applications have the source code audited?

Will Apple take responsibility if something like that were to happen to the iphone?

Besides, I already said I'm fine with malware scans, what they could simply do is audit and release a key that approves the app.

If you install an app that was not vetted you're on your own.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by potatolicious on Thursday January 28, 2010 @01:35PM (#1084590)
> "you can't protect against stupidity."

Trusting that an app on the Android marketplace is who it says it is is not stupidity. Honestly, this sort of geek arrogance ("but surely you must've known to discombobulate the zorgotron before you bazzed the foobar!") is what turns people off to geek-friendly platforms.

> "if something like that were to happen to the iphone?"

Apple at least vets who you say you are supposed to be before publishing your app. It's questionable if they will take responsibility if something makes it through, but the idea is that they're doing due diligence up front, Android is apparently not.

> "Besides, I already said I'm fine with malware scans"

This isn't malware that a malware scan will pick up. It doesn't try to take root, it doesn't nuke your files, and in fact it doesn't do anything a banking app is not expected to do. No amount of port blocking will save you, since everything this app does (according to the OS) is fully expected.

> "If you install an app that was not vetted you're on your own."

Yet... One side vets the app for you, the other one carries itself like an authoritative safe haven, but in fact isn't. Any wonder why people flock to the iPhone App Store?

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by stcredzero on Thursday January 28, 2010 @12:22PM (#1084377)
If you install an app that was not vetted you're on your own.

This is why I think Apple should sell a "Pro" version of this kit that comes with an unlocked "sandbox". I envision something that looks more like OS X, with a "iPad" app that flips you to the locked iPad OS. On the iPad side, there would be an "OS X" app that would flip you back over to the sandbox. Actually, both environments would be virtualized, so they'd be well insulated from each other.

Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by azim on Thursday January 28, 2010 @03:52PM (#1084982)
Actual case of an approved App-store app making premium-rate phone calls without informing users: http://www.theregister.co.uk/2010/01/27/iphone_admob/
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by awa on Thursday January 28, 2010 @01:58PM (#1084656)
So, Apple will make sure any user accessing email from the iPhone/iPad won't go after the money he just inherited in Nigeria.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by GHFigs on Thursday January 28, 2010 @10:51AM (#1084084)
I think it's better to just drop analogy altogether: Apple is a retailer, deciding what is fit to go on their (virtual) shelves. Most people would find this perfectly reasonable, or at least more reasonable than the sort of parental/governmental role that analogies like yours point to.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by wizard_2 on Thursday January 28, 2010 @11:25AM (#1084188)
Yes, but with Android or any other powerful OS (osx, windows, linux) you can go to anybody else's shelves and have any product they'll sell you. With the iPhone you can only shop at the company store.
Re:Tell HN: The iPad is open to hacking by GHFigs on Thursday January 28, 2010 @12:13PM (#1084354)
"Yes, but" those also suffer from that approach in ways that Apple's store doesn't. There is room for both in this world.