1. We have time. Days are 24 hours, a multiple of 12.
2. We still have time. Hours are 60 minutes, a multiple of 12.
3. Yet more time. Minutes are 60 seconds, a multiple of 12.
4. We have circles. There are 360 degrees in a circle, another multiple of 12.
5. The numbers 1, 2, 3, 4, 6 and 12 itself divide into 12 evenly. The next smallest number that has more factors than 12 is 24, which manages to be a multiple of 12.
Thanks to the seconds and minutes counting in 60s and hours and months (somewhat) counting in 12s knowing base 2, 3, 4, 6 and 12 is exactly what someone needs to work up and down.
Many baking items are also sold in units of 12 (E.G. eggs, 144 being that packet size that businesses buy in).
Finally there's the learning aspect. Learning the 12s is a lot like extending the factor tables beneath it in a way that makes sense to analog brains. It's actually not /that/ much more costly. 13 however is a whole new prime, which isn't that useful in daily life; all of the larger numbers are big enough to be handled as estimates or 'long math' precision numbers.
PS: If I could magically force all humans to learn, know, and use a new base (and that's the only option I had) I'd probably pick Octal. Hex (for the above reasons) is useful, and great for computer addressing, but less great for actual human-analog computation.
We’ve solved that in Europe, too – they’re sold in packages of 10, and businesses buy in packages of 100.
There are 12+ loaves in a baker's dozen (the exception that proves the rule)
The point on #5 is critical. Before we had a solid currency system or notion of debt, we commonly had to divide things up from a group. 12 gives a lot of flexibility in that regard. In fact, selling 12 units of something became so common that certain industries added an extra unit just to be sure that the number 12 was given (baker's dozen).
how many times do you calculate "X per year" in your head? i do it multiple times per day, and not just at work.
Seldom enough that I 'calculate it in my head' (as your comment suggests you do too) rather than memorise the 12x table.
But then again I grew up in metric country that only bothered with drilling kids up to the 10x table at school. Never had to worry about feet to inches conversions very often either.
Meanwhile, reviewing my post it reminded me of my US History teacher in middle school telling me that the Conquistadors in the Americas were after the 5 Gs: Gold, Gold, Gold, God, and Glory. I listed five things: Time, Time, Time, Degrees and Factors. I'd be thrilled if someone could say the same thing but with all of the words starting with the same letter.
Regardless, your observations seem to come down to "12 is highly composite and we use highly composite numbers for time"—valid, but interesting?
Meanwhile, your response got me to look up whether there's a metric equivalent to degrees or radians. Apparently that exists and it's a measure called Gradians. There are 400 Gradians in a circle, and 400 is not divisible by 12. I guess that idea went the way of the French Republican Calendar.
And apparently, in what I have to assume is a related use:
> In surveying, the gradian is the default unit of angles in many parts of the world.
( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gradian )
If you ever fooled around with your calculator in school, you probably noticed that it provided angle measurement conversion between degrees, radians, and gradians; the idea has certainly not gone the way of the French Republican Calendar.
Integer math.
And if there's some domain-specific application, like in carpentry, then let those people use their own units.
* Scientists and engineers culturally select tasteful units of their choice to represent time, like 1300 milliseconds or 134 hours... and everything else as well: $1.34 billion or $1.34 dollars, not $1 billion and 340 million or $1 dollar and 34 cents.
* When the number representation get too big, people just do X * 10^n where n is a tasteful choice.
* In business, days and hours are distinct concepts and should not be mixed together or confused. A person who worked for 5 days did not work 120 hours.
* Mathematicians could care less.
* Many culturally common units of time are bigger than 12 * 12.
* Calculations that are big are working-memory bound. This is the biggest point. Working memory is probably the strongest factor to large and fast calculation of any kind.
* The bigger the calculation, the more people tend to 10^n multiplicands with the distributive property, rather than 12^n, since most people work in base 10. Some engineers use 2^n or 3^n (I offer that 3^n is efficient without further explanation).
I propose the hypothesis that children who memorized up to 10 * 10 are no more likely to join or do well in the STEM fields than those who memorized up to 12 * 12.
I argue that calculations are working-memory bound, and that common uses of time go beyond 12 x 12.
For time, we often go by units of 5, 10, 15, 30, 45, 60, of these only 60 can find 12 as a divisor. You don't get to claim usefulness for all time. For the rest of these units, it's working memory doing arbitrary integer computation for us.
If we're talking about months in a year -- what's the use case for fast mental calculation? Is this the little sphere where we say 12 * n is useful?
We're talking about a policy for education for all children here. Your use cases sound really limited, if it at all impacts later cognitive performance outcomes.
It's working memory that's going to be the differentiating line between "fast mental math" and "busting out calculator" or "punching in numbers into SAS or SPSS". It's difficult to believe that Taiwanese children are going to have trouble versus American children in time based operations, if that at all continues to be a practice under the common core.
I can't imagine asking some Taiwanese business man, "Quick, what's 6 * 12 in a business context", and he goes, "Let me quickly grab a calculator."
Can you do 15 * 14? I think you can. Why can we do it? Is it because we learned 12 * 12? No. It's working-memory bound. We're doing capricious calculations with distributive property via 10^n multiplicands.
How about 24 * 17? I think you can do that too. Why can we do it? Working memory. Not because we learned 12 * 12 when we were little.
In business? In the STEM fields?
Thanks for additional info on the machinery involved.
Back in the British era of pounds, shillings, and pence, hardware had to be built to do arithmetic in that system. This resulted in one of the strangest, and most complex, purely mechanical computing devices ever built - the McClure Multiplying Punch [1], from Powers-Samas. This device came out in 1938. The comparable IBM machine was the IBM 602 Multiplying Punch, but IBM only did decimal multiplies. The McClure machine had a mechanical multiplier for pounds, shillings, and pence. It contained a physical multiplication table, made out of brass plates, and the machinery to use them for multiplication by table lookup. There's a picture of the "Pence x 7" plate.[2] That's one row of a multiplication table, and it's 12 wide, from 0 to 11. Sixpence x 7 = 3 shillings 6 pence. The brass column heights reflect that.
[1] http://www.computerconservationsociety.org/resurrection/res5... [2] http://www.computerconservationsociety.org/resurrection/imag...