News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by marcus_holmes on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:06AM (#10834627)
I had the same reaction, but not from the "see something say something" point of view, but from the conformist Twitter Thought Police.

The parallel world of not allowing any divergent thought or expression is so clear.

Weird thing, though, I love East Berlin (massively prefer it to the sterile shopping malls of West Berlin). Covered in graffiti, with all sorts of bizarre creative communities and flea markets, it's an awesome place. Is this a result of oppressive thought police, or despite it?

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by cuillevel3 on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:30AM (#10834673)
I never went to Berlin before 1989, but I'm pretty sure that happened afterwards. There was a period of maybe 10 years that changed East-Berlin. Take a look at this article: https://medium.com/matter/our-own-private-germany-6ce44ac93a...
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by realityking on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:29AM (#10834672)
Well you're comparing today's former East Berlin to todays former West Berlin. In the context of "oppressive thought police" it would be more meaningful to compare the pre 1989 state of the city.

I'm not entirely sure (I was only born in 1989 and thus haven't had a chance to visit the DDR) but I'm fairly certain there weren't a lot of graffiti back then.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by maxxxxx on Monday January 04, 2016 @08:13AM (#10835411)
Before the wall came down, there was no graffiti in east Berlin. It was all gray in gray. Graffiti came only later.

The communist states I have seen were very gray. Almost no colors.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by coldtea on Monday January 04, 2016 @08:36AM (#10835523)
>I love East Berlin (massively prefer it to the sterile shopping malls of West Berlin). Covered in graffiti, with all sorts of bizarre creative communities and flea markets, it's an awesome place. Is this a result of oppressive thought police, or despite it?

There's no East Berlin in the Cold War sense since 1989. There's only the eastern part of Berlin (and also poorest and more neglected). So this might explain that.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by marcus_holmes on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:08AM (#10836329)
ah ok, that makes sense, so an explosion of creativity and anarchic expression since the wall came down. cool thanks :)
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by golergka on Monday January 04, 2016 @04:37AM (#10834692)
> Get used to it, the whole world is becoming East Germany.

Are you honestly suggesting that raising an alert about a strange bag without an owner is the same thing as telling authorities that your neighbors are telling jokes about politburo?

What the fuck is wrong with you people? It's one thing to be privacy advocate. It's another thing to bring this thing up to this level of idiocy.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by dang on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:21PM (#10837332)
> What the fuck is wrong with you people?

This comment breaks the HN guidelines. Please comment civilly and substantively, even when another comment is provocative.

https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html

https://news.ycombinator.com/newswelcome.html

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by sillysaurus3 on Monday January 04, 2016 @07:16AM (#10835146)
What the fuck is wrong with you people? It's one thing to be privacy advocate. It's another thing to bring this thing up to this level of idiocy.

Please don't do this. It poisons the conversation, and your point would be more persuasive without the personal attack.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by golergka on Monday January 04, 2016 @07:29AM (#10835209)
You are right, of course. I shouldn't have used this language. But when I hear stuff like that I feel like a sexual assault victim who's witnessing someone saying "he VERBALLY RAPED me" after a rude conversation (stupid example, wish I had a better one at hand). Secret police and oppression by the government _are_ serious issues, and they get diluted by this ridiculous outlook.
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by DanBC on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:00AM (#10835886)
You can downvote or flag the trolls.
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by stefantalpalaru on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:12AM (#10835953)
Good observation, flagging is our way of snitching and "trolls" are our "enemies of the people".

Now that you mention it, I don't think I ever flagged somebody on HN. Could it be because I was born and raised in communist Romania?

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by maxerickson on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:19AM (#10835996)
Flagging is the equivalent of walking away from a conversation with an obnoxious person, not the equivalent of reporting someone to the secret police.

If you welcome and tolerate every single conversation that someone tries to engage you in, more power to you.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by Nutmog on Monday January 04, 2016 @07:03AM (#10835090)
The former might kill a few people. The latter, if it was allowed to spread freely, might collapse an entire country and kill thousands or more in the ensuing chaos. All countries have laws to protect their own existence. Actions that threaten that are called "treason". I personally think treason should be allowed as long as it doesn't harm individual people directly. But it can be punished with the death penalty in the US, so a lot of people probably think it's serious.

"the United States Code at 18 U.S.C. § 2381 states "whoever, owing allegiance to the United States, levies war against them or adheres to their enemies, giving them aid and comfort within the United States or elsewhere, is guilty of treason and shall suffer death, or shall be imprisoned not less than five years and ..." " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treason#United_States

Most people are not idiots. If you find yourself thinking that, it's a good clue that you may be judging them according to your own culture and preconceptions even though theirs may be different.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by golergka on Monday January 04, 2016 @07:15AM (#10835143)
> if it was allowed to spread freely

Everything is bad when it's driven to the point of absurd. But this description:

> if it was allowed to spread freely, might collapse an entire country and kill thousands or more in the ensuing chaos

is something that the former can become much easier than the latter.

I've seen how a country goes from a western democracy to a quasi-totalitarian state myself. When you describe US and european surveillance programs as something that leads you towards totalitarian dystopia, it's a little like a boy who likes to cry "wolf". These dangers are real indeed, but they don't come where you think they come from, and they are not the only dangers in the universe you have to be afraid of.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by selimthegrim on Monday January 04, 2016 @08:10AM (#10835403)
Hungary?
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by golergka on Monday January 04, 2016 @09:40AM (#10835807)
Unfortunately, I don't know history of Hungary well enough to understand what exactly are you referring to. Can you be more exact, what are you talking about in my comment?
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by selimthegrim on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:18PM (#10837304)
Meaning I was guessing that Hungary was the country turning away from democracy that you were referring to.
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by Nutmog on Monday January 04, 2016 @08:21AM (#10835441)
> is something that the former can become much easier than the latter.

It's not easy to compare. Pakistan and others have terrorism but Syria, Egypt, Libya, Tunisia and others have overthrown governments which might have been prevented with more Stasi-ism. The US is more stable than them so it can allow people more freedom to communicate - but still not complete freedom - see state secrets and the existence of wiretapping at all even on known criminals.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by golergka on Monday January 04, 2016 @09:40AM (#10835804)
Late tzarist Russia had terrorism. Weimar republic didn't have terrorism per se, but it had militant groups enacting violence against their enemies in order to puruse political goals — some would name it terrorism, although I prefer a more strict definition.

In other words, there were at least several instances in history where appearance of militant groups that violated state's monopoly on violence led, in the end, to these groups gaining power, and being much more violent and "bad" exactly because of their violent history.

On the other hand, I don't believe I know a single instance where a democratic regimes turned into totalitarian or authoritarian government _because_of_ technological advances that allowed it more control.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by coldtea on Monday January 04, 2016 @08:33AM (#10835508)
>When you describe US and european surveillance programs as something that leads you towards totalitarian dystopia, it's a little like a boy who likes to cry "wolf".

Not sure why you'd say that. The government in many dystopias ("1984" etc) had way less surveillance capabilities than the governments have today.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by golergka on Monday January 04, 2016 @09:34AM (#10835776)
1984 is fiction. Good fiction. Convincing. But fiction.

Reality is different.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by coldtea on Monday January 04, 2016 @11:25AM (#10836429)
Nobody said 1894 is not fiction -- it was mentioned because someone said about dystopias.

Of course reality is different. That doesn't mean it's also not worse than 1984 in some aspects. The kind of torture and killings people that got in the hands of the government suffered in Pinochet's Chile, for example, make 1984 look very tame.

And in the US too, government surveillance programs have hurt real people for decades -- way beyond McCarthy, Hoover and/or the Watergate.

It's mostly/only people who haven't suffered from something like this, and can't possible fathom they could be targets themselves, that dismiss concerns about state surveillance and abuses with a cavalier attitude that it's just "crying wolf".

People who have seen their politicians doing all these things and more in their countries (and getting away with it a lot, with the occasional trial), are much more savvy to this kind of abuse than people who think state agencies are mostly good guys plus/minus a few "rotten apples", and that their government killing/blackmailing/spying etc on people on their soil can't (and hasn't) happened.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by stefantalpalaru on Monday January 04, 2016 @09:57AM (#10835871)
There was no strange bag in the public service announcement. Only "if you see something, say something" and information about law enforcement offices inside the underground stations where the snitches are supposed to go and point out that some weird tourist is taking photos of vital infrastructure.

If you find all this normal, there's something wrong with you. You got used to living in fear. Got used to needing to blend in even if you're doing nothing wrong.

I bet you also got used to those neighborhood watch signs warning you that loitering and cruising will be reported to the police, even if they are not illegal.

You already live in East Germany, you just don't know it yet.

Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by golergka on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:01AM (#10835889)
No, I find it normal because there's more than one terror attack per day around me.
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by stefantalpalaru on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:13AM (#10835961)
Where do you live, in occupied Palestine?
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by golergka on Monday January 04, 2016 @10:14AM (#10835967)
Oh right, I forgot that I'm a jew, so I deserve it. Thanks for the reminder.
[dead]
Re:East Germany thrived on snitching lovers, fickle friends ... by dang on Monday January 04, 2016 @01:23PM (#10837345)
We've banned this account for repeatedly breaking the HN guidelines.