I grew up in a scientific community. People innovated and did research because they were passionate about knowledge and learning. Of course, some of them went on to create startups like Biogen but money was never the biggest motivator. I don't buy the argument that taxing the wealthy slightly more than now stifles innovation.
How is it better even at all, even not by much?
If we imagine that the small group of central planners were actually democratically elected (in the Soviet Union they were not, although they ideologically pretended to be), it's unequivicably _more democratic_ to have them making decisions compared to unelected billionaires who are not in any way accountable to voters.
I'm not quite sure what you mean by 'democratic' when you say you can't think of anything more democratic than those with more money having more political power. I don't see how there's some specific threshold where this becomes more or less true than it was at smaller level of inequality, although it's certainly _less_ democratic the greater the level of inequality, it seems fairly proportional to me rather than there being a 'threshold'.
Keep the inequality. Some people will make better decisions and then others. The people who make better decisions for example investing the money into research should be rewarded with money and the ability to decide how to best further allocate it including buying a bigger house for themselves or hire a house cleaner because they are busy innovating. There are no problems with that. The problem happens when they become too powerful. The way to prevent that is a progressive tax. In this case, make it very hard but not impossible to get above controlling 1,000,000. No one person and no small group of people are better at making decisions than a large group of people. That is what I mean by wealth equality is democratic. Perhaps, it is better to say there needs to be a wealth equilibrium rather than wealth equality.
I also still don't understand why there'd be some 'threshold' (threshold of what?) at which rich people would start making bad decisions (or at least decisions that are bad for everyone that's not them?), whereas before that they would be making 'good' decisions (meaning decisions that benefit people other than them, I guess?).
I'm still not sure what you think 'democracy' consists of exactly.
[1]http://www.amazon.com/The-Wisdom-Crowds-James-Surowiecki/dp/...
That's a very negative attitude to have towards people with wealth above some magical number you deem "too-much".
People will get very illogical and angry when they see you blatantly stealing from their children. I know I will, because at the end of the day, I work for my progeny. An estate/inheritance tax is not taking away from my well-being, but from that of my children.
So, instead of fixing the problems with your form of governance, you decide to impose even more tyranny over the few who can possibly take advantage of it. The problem is not the money that allows them to possibly take advantage, but the corruptible system you have in place. Use that effort in making it actually noble like it's claimed to be.
The problem now comes that society in general are not happy with the outcomes of the above. It's now less about how to provide for a stable, secure society and infrastructure, and more about how will we "fix everything". I believe the very existence of a state means people will want it to fix things, because it's there.
And now, someone needs to pay for all the "fixing".
But that's exactly what you're advocating. According to this entire discussion, the state itself is broken in this case, and you want to use the state to cap/prevent the ultra-rich as a remedy to it being broken. How does that not count as "fixing things"?
>"We don't need billionaires."
Whether we need them or not is irrelevant, they simply exist. Or is their existence something you want to "fix"?
>"With the number of people worth more than $250,000,000 that we have now is just a massive disaster that ended with $15,000,000,000,000 debt on the backs of everybody."
No, sorry, you have no one but your politicians and political system to blame for that. If you know you have a fallible/corruptible system, and don't change it, then the fault is on you. By you I mean you and the general population. Consequently, if your political system means it is slow to change, and is susceptible to the whims of the public that is easily swayed by the media, then you have to rethink democracy.
Inheritance tax, on the other hand, usually has a "lower-bound" that prevents the very poor from being affected.
Taxes on investment? You mean, capital gains? Or something like dividends?
Taxes on investment are complex. Considering the fact that most humans do not have anything approaching a real investment portfolio, it's hard to understand what you could mean when you say this kind of tax is regressive.
A properly progressive income tax should mean that more people can join the investment class. If the taxation within the investment class is actually regressive, then maybe we worry about that when the majority of humans have this problem.
When I think regressive taxes, I think things that are flat fees, or else things like fica, which cut out after a certain income.
What it sounds like you are trying to say is that it's not "progressive" enough for your liking. And then you turn the definitions upside down and label it "regressive".
This actually reminds me of Chomsky, who said that if people are really allowed to vote, they might decide to spend more on education and universal health care, rather than on nuclear weapons. Oh, the horrors!
Poverty is always relative and is inextricable from the issue of inequality.
But this has nothing to do with inequality. It has to do with "too many people below economic level X". If this seems related to inequality it's because you've already bought into the pie fallacy.
What exactly do you intend to do to change that? If you start everyone at a baseline level, some of them are going to be smarter, stronger, savvier or whatever, and will be more successful, and thus wealthier, and thus have greater access to whatever benefits that wealth can buy. Even if you zero everyone out each generation, genes matter.
Unless you are artificially suppressing people from rising above mediocrity, you will have some that do better than others.
In concrete terms, I don't believe those with pre-existing access to capital should receive privileged tax treatment. I'm im favor of lowering taxes on earned income and raising taxes on inheritance and investment income.
If you want positive social mobility, then you need to encourage generational wealth. The rags-to-riches, pull-yourself-up-by-the-bootstraps in a single generation story is more romantic, but the more realistic path to advancement is to build on the foundations of the family nest egg. Taking a haircut on that family wealth each generation makes it harder to climb the ladder from working class to lower middle class to upper middle class.
There's the pie fallacy: it would seem that alleviating poverty = alleviating inequality, when for most of history it has been exactly the opposite.
To me, this sentence and the ones that follow are by far the most salient point.
How many Zuckerbergs, Gates, Brins, Pages and Bezos are we missing out on due to the fact that huge swaths of our country do not have the ability to fully explore and develop their talents? How many trillions in lost GDP does that amount to?
To me, this entire debate is a missed opportunity to discuss inequality on the basis of shared wealth, growth and prosperity. Instead we tend to debate these things on a moral dimension which immediately politicizes and polarizes the matter. See renewable energy for another example of how that works.