Deaths in all road user groups is about 2,000 per year in the UK. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/annual-road-fatal...
Estimates for deaths caused by air pollution are usually stated as being about 30,000 per year, but that number could be much higher. http://www.theguardian.com/environment/2015/apr/02/air-pollu...
Yes, air pollution presumably causes a bunch of premature deaths, but clearly air pollution can not directly kill you. In the meantime, road traffic accidents is one, if not the biggest factor in the death of otherwise totally healthy people like teenagers, who we would easily expect to live another 40 years.
In any case, the magnitude of the problem doesn't exactly matter, as banning diesel cars doesn't solve the pollution deaths. Normal gasoline cars have the same pollution problems, if only on a somewhat lesser scale, particularly when used for short distances as customary in the city.
As such, yes, we still have to get rid of cars in cities to fix this.
People die from pollution induced asthma attack. That's pretty direct.
That's not in the slightest true. A well running gasoline car produces so few pollutants that some actually produce exhaust that is cleaner than the air that entered it.
No diesel can claim that.
I'd be happier to fix both problems at once, but fixing just one would go a long way.
There is no healthy threshold for particulate concentration and other pollution, even if safety standards want to create this illusion. It's a continuous world, after all.
Sure, there is an indirect health problem with pollution, but there is also a much more direct health problem: cars causing fatal accidents. The best way is hence to fix the problem at the root: personal cars do not belong in cities, and cars do not belong in pedestrian areas.