Re:The Closed Mind of Richard Dawkins (2014)
by pron on Friday January 01, 2016 @01:05AM
(#10821223)
> Scripture or not, followers of Judaism surely must have some common beliefs which can be articulated and examined.
Articulated -- definitely. Examined? I don't see how. How do you examine the belief that one should not light a fire on the Sabbath or that one should eat matzo on the first day of Passover? Jewish "belief" is simply accepting the obligation to follow a long set of rules. Prominent Jewish philosophers explicitly say that those rules have no purpose or consequence (though others disagree).
The topic is Dawkins, and his focus has been Christianity. In the submitted page, he's accused of closed-mindedness in that context.
A big part of Christianity is flatly believing things which are written in the Holy Bible, and so if we critically examine Christianity, that's going to be a big part of the argument. It's not an attack on the Bible as such, but its use by a group.
It may be that Judaism doesn't have this same "attack surface" due to its different treatment of scriptures. Scripture or not, followers of Judaism surely must have some common beliefs which can be articulated and examined.