News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by _pmf_ on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:20PM (#10819156)
I think Wikipedia will become the best case study in how bureaucracy cripples a working society. 80% of the effort of creating new content is following byzantine processes and procedures.

While I admit that these processes work for consistency of content, I cannot in the least observe any noticeable quality improvements, and the reason is that valuable contributors with deep domain knowledge will not invest the time to satisfy the OCD of some arbitrary editor suffering from Asperger.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by digler999 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:22PM (#10819163)
> OCD of some arbitrary editor suffering from Asperger.

Is it really necessary to use mental illnesses in a pejorative way to make your point ? How do you think it makes people feel who legitimately suffer from those illnesses ?

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by ars on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:41PM (#10819253)
> Is it really necessary to use mental illnesses in a pejorative way to make your point ?

He's not. That is, actually, the real problem. He's not just using it as some sort of insult but explaining the specific problem.

I've run into editors like that (they even proudly boast about it on their user page, so I'm not just projecting). I've had enough run-ins with them, and people like them, that I gave up on editing.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by digler999 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:09PM (#10819407)
> That is, actually, the real problem.

So all wikipedia editors have Asperger's and OCD ? That seems astronomically unlikely, don't you ?

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by ars on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:20PM (#10819472)
Is there some requirement that it be all?

It's enough that it's some, to make it impossible to edit anything. In fact it can even be a small minority, but given that they spend (as far as I can tell) almost their entire day on it, a small number can have a huge influence.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by hubridnoxx on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:15PM (#10819440)
PC hypersensitivity..
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by jzd on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:27PM (#10819505)
No
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by mahouse on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:29PM (#10819201)
It should make them aware that they should refrain from holding any position where they have to deal with people. I am sure you have never edited Wikipedia; the amount of users and admins that more than obviously suffer from autism spectrum disorders and OCDs is very, very high, and they are crippling the bureaucratic processes of the wiki.

I know these words are "ugly" or "not politically correct" but I think just looking the other way is not helping anybody.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by Retra on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:43PM (#10819260)
Maybe you should refrain from trying to diagnose mental disorders by pretending to analyze Wikipedia editor culture.

That's not even a disorder, it's just plain stupid.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by Marcomasino on Thursday December 31, 2015 @04:38PM (#10819832)
Aw, come on, lighten up, it's just an online forum. Maybe people develop Asperger traits from working in this field. Like one time I asked a college did he know what the time was, he replied YES and walked off :)
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by digler999 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:12PM (#10819419)
> I know these words are "ugly" or "not politically correct"

It's not about PC. It's about violating their rights. Please, post your full medical charts, prescription lists, and any mental health counseling notes or treatments for addiction you've ever undertaken, so I can use them to mock you.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by mahouse on Thursday December 31, 2015 @11:28PM (#10821101)
None. :)

And I'm not violating the rights of somebody by pointing out they have an illness, sorry.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by return0 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:37PM (#10819556)
Given the nature of the work they have to do, it's pretty much a required qualification to have OCD.
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by DanBC on Thursday December 31, 2015 @04:46PM (#10819864)
That's not what OCD is.

If you care about how you come across: You sound as ignorant as someone saying "I want my accountants to be Jews. They're good with money". (Although I accept that this level of ignorance about OCD is very common.)

http://www.mind.org.uk/information-support/types-of-mental-h...

>> Obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD) is described as an anxiety disorder. The condition has two main parts: obsessions and compulsions.

>> Obsessions are unwelcome thoughts, images, urges or doubts that repeatedly appear in your mind; for example, thinking that you have been contaminated by dirt and germs, or experiencing a sudden urge to hurt someone.

>> These obsessions are often frightening or seem so horrible that you can’t share them with others. The obsession interrupts your other thoughts and makes you feel very anxious.

[...]

>> Compulsions are repetitive activities that you feel you have to do. This could be something like repeatedly checking a door to make sure it is locked or repeating a specific phrase in your head to prevent harm coming to a loved one.

>> The aim of a compulsion is to try and deal with the distress caused by the obsessive thoughts and relieve the anxiety you are feeling. However, the process of repeating these compulsions is often distressing and any relief you feel is often short-lived.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by return0 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @05:07PM (#10819970)
Thanks for the enlightening comment; i wasn't really trying to offer a definition of OCD. Yes , it's common that people talk to OCD to refer to this thing specifically: "Compulsions are repetitive activities that you feel you have to do.", even when the action is not repetitive.
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by Marcomasino on Thursday December 31, 2015 @02:53PM (#10819307)
I know exactly what _pmf_ means. I used deal with a self declared Asperger who was top class in his field. The thing is whenever I asked him do you know how to fix this problem. The answer was invariably, 'sorry I don't know how to do that'. Of course I should have phrased it as, I am having difficulties in solving this problem and was wondering if you would advise me on finding a solution.
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by digler999 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:14PM (#10819430)
Wow, one anecdotal piece of evidence. Your postulate must now be proven. Tell me some of your anecdotes about black people or mexicans while you're at it. Remember, by your logic, any single sample speaks for the whole population. This should be interesting! :)
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by Marcomasino on Thursday December 31, 2015 @04:25PM (#10819772)
Having worked with and directed people of differing ethnic backgrounds, I would pick the Chinese as best to work with. The worst who shall remain nameless, were either augmentative dishonest or lazy and some were as thick as two very thick planks glued together. You had to speak to them in very short sentences and not use big words and still they didn't get it. I didn't experience a large enough sample to form an opinion as to whether it was environmental or genetic.
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by danso on Thursday December 31, 2015 @06:22PM (#10820289)
Initial comment from you (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10819307):

> I used deal with a self declared Asperger who was top class in his field. The thing is whenever I asked him do you know how to fix this problem. The answer was invariably, 'sorry I don't know how to do that'.

From your comment above:

> The worst [group of people] who shall remain nameless, were either augmentative dishonest or lazy and some were as thick as two very thick planks glued together. You had to speak to them in very short sentences and not use big words and still they didn't get it.

So...how do you know that either:

A. The "self-declared Asperger" is actually quite reasonable and you just happen to be in his "worst" group of people...I don't mean that you necessarily have those qualities, just that he's chosen to treat you as if you did, based on his past experiences with people of your kind?

B. That you yourself don't have the stereotypical behavioral symptoms Aspergers and that this "worst" group of people may not really deserve your harsh judgment?

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by digler999 on Thursday December 31, 2015 @09:02PM (#10820804)
> who shall remain nameless

"PC hypersensitive" coward

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by jzd on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:33PM (#10819535)
^ this guy is why we can't have nice things
Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by c3534l on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:00PM (#10819349)
> 80% of the effort of creating new content is following byzantine processes and procedures

You literally just press edit, make your changes, and then press save. There is zero bureaucracy in adding content. The bureaucracy comes into play with there is unresolved conflict and disagreement, when there is a controversy over how an article is written. In that case, there are definite, objective(ish) standards and rules by which those arguments can come to a resolution of some kind. I suppose in a more hierarchical structure there would be less bureaucracy when there are disagreements and the next person in charge would simply decide which view he thought was more correct. But the traditional structure of writing an encyclopedia is filled with gatekeepers who have the final, single decision without much of a need to reach consensus. Depending on your view this could be good or it could be bad.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by mortenjorck on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:15PM (#10819441)

  You literally just press edit, make your changes, and then press save.
You literally just press edit, make your changes, press save, and then wait a few minutes to an hour for your edit to be reverted.

Seriously, though, it's disingenuous to suggest that editing is so simple - to be pedantic, yes, the edit itself is free of bureaucracy, but in the majority of cases I've observed, the real effort is in making an edit (not even a controversial one) stick.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by x1798DE on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:40PM (#10819570)
Almost none of my edits ever get reverted, including even fairly major changes, other than in contentious articles or when it comes down to an editorial decision.

Generally I'm either making minor fixes (basically nothing you would dispute), or when I add something, it's cited.

When there is a conflict, it's probably beyond most people to figure out how to handle the conflict resolution process (which generally, in my experience, is fruitful), but if you're adding high quality content, that rarely comes up - it's just that when it does it takes up a disproportionate amount of your time.

Re:The rise and decline of Wikipedia [pdf] by ddingus on Thursday December 31, 2015 @03:24PM (#10819489)
Yes, an add is easy as you say. However, it will be reverted nearly all of the time, and that is where the trouble is.

Why contribute when the idea of others actually seeing the benefit of doing it is so painful?