I suspect we might need a "taxonomy of trust" so to speak, that allows the trust data to be anonymized and aggregated into commonly-accepted meanings of trust contexts, trust roles, trust relationships, etc. That might let these companies to release the trust data into such a format through a blockchain perhaps, and be able to participate in consuming the aggregated data. I'd need someone well-versed in game theory to figure out if an advantage is conferred to "leeches"; a company in such a scenario who only consumes the aggregated data but never send into the blockchain what they accumulate on their own customers. I think that's a real danger with such a scheme, but am not sure how to strongly dissuade that behavior.
What are your thoughts modeling respect not just as a unitary quality (still highly useful for quick, ad hoc, high-level evaluation), but also along crowd-created and crowd-defined axes? Then people can refine their description of respect and for example, say they agree with one crowd-group's definition of "good manager" for a specific person, but at the same time that person is not respected as another crowd-group's definition of a "good leader".
Gaming reputation systems over extended time periods and via aliased entities is a perennial problem. What are your thoughts on random latencies before respect scoring is evaluated on new respect data for an entity, securely tying a hash based upon fully-sequenced DNA to real-person accounts, interaction of entities in a specific context (someone might be respected as a great athlete, considered toxic in one of the companies they own, but respected in a different company), and tracking corporate aliasing (through mergers, acquisitions, spin-offs, name changes, etc.)?
> The Chinese government is building an omnipotent "social credit" system that is meant to rate each citizen's trustworthiness.
we don't have an effective data driven reputation system. we use gameable heuristics to track social capial.
when metrics for evaluation are flawed, people behave in ways that exploit the flaws even if they increase the likelihood of failure.
"we are not rewarded for necessary grunt work as much as shiny advances", for example. That's a failure of the reputation system to account for the value of that work.
My solution to this problem is a mathematical reputation system based on the same concept as page rank. The system is available here:
github.com/neyer/respect
I'd love your feedback.