Re:New York is installing its promised public gigabit Wi-Fi
by Joeri on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @06:13AM
(#10811642)
How would you arrange it practically though? You would have to distribute sim cards, and people would have to swap those out with their normal sim card rendering them unreachable by phone. That's ofcourse assuming their phone isn't carrier-locked. Wifi seems a lot more practical unless phones are redesigned to cover this usage pattern.
Re:New York is installing its promised public gigabit Wi-Fi
by pdabbadabba on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @09:01AM
(#10812048)
> mwsherman's original question was "Why would municipalities offer free wifi rather than free 4G?"
This isn't quite how I read the comment, but here are some pretty good answers, I think:
1. They would have to either purchase suitable licensed spectrum (literally hundreds of millions of dollars in NYC) or find an existing carrier with which to form an MVNO relationship with generous enough terms that the city could afford to "resell" the service for free.
2. 4G would probably require NYC to deal with distributing phones or SIM cards, and then users would have to figure out how to unlock their devices.
Re:New York is installing its promised public gigabit Wi-Fi
by DanBC on Wednesday December 30, 2015 @05:02AM
(#10811489)
> But my point is that if someone has wifi, they also very likely have a smartphone that's capabale of receiving a 4G signal, even if they cannot afford a data plan from their cell network provider.
That's a bit of an assumption. I'd like to see some numbers to support it. I know a bunch of people who have wifi capable devices but not devices capable of 4g. Or they have older smartphones that are not 4g capable.
mwsherman's original question was "Why would municipalities offer free wifi rather than free 4G?". jws thought it might be important for folks who didn't have data plans. But my point is that if someone has wifi, they also very likely have a smartphone that's capabale of receiving a 4G signal, even if they cannot afford a data plan from their cell network provider.