News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by scottlocklin on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @03:24PM (#10808832)
It's sad what's happened to physics. I remember being at an SPIE meeting for optical physics; some of my work on X-ray microscopes was being presented there. I happened upon a giant auditorium filled to the nostrils with people debating life on other planets. Debating. Life on other planets. These folks were full time thinking about this. They weren't doing anything about it; it reminded me of a weed-and-beer-fueled bull session in a dorm room, except all these people were effectively professional exobiologists being paid to have weed and beer fueled bull sessions on exobiology. It didn't even rise to the level of an interesting Science Fiction short story. This at a conference for people doing actual science, people who develop telescopes, optical computers and other optical doodads, as well as new mathematical techniques to master different kinds of optical tricks.

The "physicist" who has this big idea is actually a cosmologist and the first few sentences of his wiki page indicate he is a fairly fruity one. Cosmology itself has gone off in embarrassing directions, and is vastly too large in comparison to its actual importance to the human race. I'm not sure anything has actually been figured out by a professional Cosmologist, though they use cool math sometimes. The actual cosmological results we have come from people doing actual science; astronomers, radio engineers, nuclear physicists, stat mech guys. Mind you, if cosmology could actually figure things out, I'd be all for it, but it seems they mostly do "gee whiz" think pieces which feature some differential geometry and noodle theory. And, apparently, untestable mystical whoop-dee-do about consciousness.

I'm gonna get off my high horse in a minute, but this sort of "celebritization" of science is obnoxious. People used to hang on the words of Fermi and Einstein, and considered their weird speculations to be interesting because those men proved their scientific acuity in other domains; actually increasing human understanding of nature. Now a days we canonize guys like this to do the "gee whiz" think pieces that people enjoy reading articles about ... and they are not of the caliber to justify anyone paying attention to their weird ideas. They're speculative types: science fiction authors who know some impressive math. They don't deserve the appellation of "scientist" let alone "physicist" as they do not study nature in a scientific manner. While Peter Woit has done some admirable work exposing the impostures of the noodle theorists, we really need someone to cleanse the temple of science of such people in general.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by ethanbond on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @03:31PM (#10808866)
This is incredibly shortsighted. First, at least some portion of science has always been dedicated "debating" things. That doesn't mean they're being unhelpful, especially since those are the types of debates which help to steer resources towards practical efforts.

How do you decide which telescope to build if you haven't decided, without such telescope, what exactly it's supposed to be looking at?

It's also worth noting that theoretical inquiries can be incredibly helpful. You know, like all of Einstein's work. After all, he was a mathematician just playing with numbers and then trusting their results – something most "real scientists" were too skeptical to do because the results didn't look like what they expected.

Of course, it didn't help that a lot of Einstein's (and other theoretical scientists) ideas were, at the time, untestable mystical whoop-dee-do, either.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by scottlocklin on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @07:43PM (#10810076)
It is supremely unhelpful when 1/3 or more of physics department tenure track positions are going to people who are not doing science, which is the present situation. As far as I am concerned, nobody needs a day job doing this sort of thing. It is recreational philosophical speculation, salted with mathematics. It would be far more productive to pay professors of physics to develop renormalization group theory for the game of go or something; at least that is testable, even if it isn't physics any more than the paper under discussion is.

You apparently don't understand the difference between "you know, like all of Einstein's work" and nonsense like this. Virtually all of Einstein's work was based on experiment (he won the Nobel for explaining the photoelectric effect), and all of it was/is testable both in principle and in practice. The sort of wanking in this paper simply isn't science in any sense of the word. It isn't even testable in principle. It is no more science than a ghost story or a damp t-shirt with an equation on it.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @03:58PM (#10809029)
Um, no. Einstein's ideas were, at least in part, testable. Parts of them were confirmed rather quickly.
Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by ethanbond on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @04:16PM (#10809117)
Parts of some of them were confirmed rather quickly.

Other parts of some of them are still unconfirmed, and a subset of those are still well beyond our foreseeable capability of testing. Black holes are one notable prediction that we have virtually no way to confirm.

What's your point? I'm not saying Einstein got things wrong, I'm saying that immediately dismissing science which is not immediately testable is risky. Especially as more and more of the low hanging fruit is picked – cutting edge scientific ideas are going to be more and more difficult to test.

Compare the Cavendish experiment to the Michelson-Morley experiment to the Large Hadron to... Creating a black hole?

Seems to be a steep increase in difficulty. It should be expected.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by scottlocklin on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @07:51PM (#10810111)
Einstein didn't come up with the idea of black holes. Laplace did; before General Relativity for that matter. Meanwhile, Laplace gets to speculate about such things without being considered a goofball because he invented big chunks of mathematics, optics and physics.

In fact, nobody in the physics community spoke of black holes at all until the 1960s when they began converting agricultural colleges into warehouses for people who speculate on untestable things.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by AnimalMuppet on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @06:02PM (#10809635)
OK. This idea that we're actually discussing... is it testable? Is it even testable in principle?
Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by ethanbond on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @06:13PM (#10809691)
I believe that's the whole point. This is someone trying to distill a seemingly intractable problem into a testable form.

I think the answer for now is "no," but that's precisely the question he is attempting to answer: "is consciousness something that can be modeled in such a way that we can answer whether or not it is [x]?"

Not: "is consciousness [x]?"

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by cetacea on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @08:19PM (#10810192)
> I'm not sure anything has actually been figured out by a professional Cosmologist

You are 100% wrong. Several Nobel prizes have been awarded for seminal results in cosmology, like observation of the cosmic microwave background and the discovery of accelerated metric expansion.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by scottlocklin on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @08:43PM (#10810253)
The observation of cosmic microwave background radiation was done by Penzias and Wilson, working on practical stuff (though Wilson was an astronomer, I think by training). It was explained as cosmic background by Dicke, who was a tremendously productive optical and atomic physicist. None of these guys were considered "cosmologists" -none of them did "cosmology" and the title of "cosmologist" didn't even exist in those days. Penzias actually caught a lot of flack as director of Bell Labs for shutting down a lot of the speculative stuff there.

I'm not sure what the other thing you're referring to is, but I used to go to some of Joe Taylor's seminars: he was an astronomer, not a cosmologist. Cosmologists are people who publish papers that can't be tested by people like Penzias, Wilson and Taylor.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by cetacea on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @08:53PM (#10810279)
> Cosmologists are people who publish papers that can't be tested

Once again you are wrong. Mather, Smoot, Perlmutter, and Riess are all cosmologists. Their Nobel prizes were awarded for results in cosmology.

Your idiosyncratic redefinition of the word "cosmology" is completely at odds with how the word is used in the physics community.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by placeybordeaux on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @03:49PM (#10808973)
All too often people think that being smart is one dimensional trait that applies all over the place.
Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by sageikosa on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @04:19PM (#10809135)
Or that consciousness is unitary :-)