News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by Animats on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @03:17PM (#10808799)
Looking at the ArXIV article, the key ideas apparently come from "Consciousness as Integrated Information: a Provisional Manifesto," by Giulio Tononi, who is a psychiatrist in Wisconsin.[1] His two big claims are that, for an information processing system to be conscious, it needs to have two separate traits:

1. Information: It has to have a large repertoire of accessible states, i.e., the ability to store a large amount of information.

2. Integration: This information must be integrated into a unified whole, i.e., it must be impossible to decompose the system into nearly independent parts, because otherwise these parts would subjectively feel like two separate conscious entities.

1) is reasonable, although it doesn't say much about how much memory is required. 2) is clearly bogus - we know that biological brains don't work that way. They have at least a hundred or so subunits handling different functions. Some are very specific, such as face recognition. Tononi says that in his paper: "different parts of the cerebral cortex are specialized for different functions, yet a vast network of connections allows these parts to interact profusely." So he admits it's not one big component; it's a network of components with explicit, limited connectivity.

Where Tonini is coming from is the concept of "qualia".[2] This is a philosophical concept, roughly "The 'what it is like' character of mental states. The way it feels to have mental states such as pain, seeing red, smelling a rose, etc." Toroni hypothesizes that qualia can be (are?) represented as points in a space of 2^n dimensions. He writes "Each axis is labeled with the probability p for that state, going from 0 to 1, so that a repertoire (i.e.,a probability distribution on the possible states of the complex) corresponds to a point in Q (Fig. 5)." This is similar to the internal state of an artificial neural network.

The physics paper conjectures that if only we had some materials (?) called "computronium" and "perceptronium", we could get work done in qualia space, through a process where energy is removed from the system in a way vaguely similar to simulated annealing. There's a lot of math and discussion around the idea that some randomness has to be applied to make the thing go; not enough, and it stalls out; too much, and it's just noise. There's a suggestion that certain forms of noise will make it work better. All this sound vaguely similar to the way the random initialization of ANNs matters a lot, and recent work has made ANNs better by choosing the random initial conditions in certain ways. Neither paper mentions what's going on in the ANN world, yet they seem to be approaching some of the same concepts. I'm not an ANN expert; someone in that field may have a better idea of whether the concepts are related.

All this is from the "consciousness is special and magic" crowd. Both authors assume that is the case, and try to reason from there. That's closer to theology than physics.

[1] http://www.biolbull.org/content/215/3/216.full.pdf+html [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualia

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by lawpoop on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @03:30PM (#10808863)
> 2) is clearly bogus - we know that biological brains don't work that way.

But the brain entire is not consciousness (it's probably in the prefrontal cortex). Some parts of the brain, such as heartbeat, object tracking, etc, are obviously not integrated into consciousness.

It's not one big component, but it at least has to integrate all the components of consciousness (again, not all the brain functions), or else we wouldn't have the apparent sensation that "I" am an indivisible whole. By "I", I mean my consciousness, my will and personality, not my body, which is obviously made up of parts, including the brain and its parts.

It might be an illusion, but that doesn't mean that that illusion is not worthy of study, since it is probably the main thing that defines the human experience.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by sgt101 on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @03:43PM (#10808934)
>But the brain entire is not consciousness (it's probably in the prefrontal cortex). Some parts of the brain, such as heartbeat, object tracking, etc, are obviously not integrated into consciousness.

So only mammals are conscious? Sucks to not be an Eagle I guess! Beware zombie Dinosaurs!

Sometimes I have distinctly non integrated experiences, like when I speak and the sentences flow from me containing grammatically correct concepts in logical order, and I didn't have anything to do with it, but there it is an argument that "I" made.

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by lawpoop on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @04:08PM (#10809075)
I think other animals, such as certain birds (crows, parrots), might be conscious, maybe octopuses, but that's just my pet theory. To be sure, we'd need a definition of what consciousness is exactly (more than "I'm pretty sure I am conscious, and other people, too") , and probably really good brain scan technology, far better than what we have now.
Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by explorer666 on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @04:56PM (#10809350)
I like this definition I've heard from Sam Harris (paraphrasing): An entity is conscious if there is something that it's like to be that entity.
Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by improv32 on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @03:46PM (#10808954)
Are you totally sure that you're an indivisible whole?

http://www.meltingasphalt.com/neurons-gone-wild/

Re:Why Some Physicists Are Saying Consciousness Is a State o... by lawpoop on Tuesday December 29, 2015 @04:09PM (#10809079)
No, I'm obviously not in an objective sense, but my _subjective experience_ is that I am. That subjective experience is what we're interested in studying. That's what people are referring to when they say they are conscious.