The fundamental principle of the paperclip argument is that the motivations of an AI will not necessarily align with our interests. An AI may do all sorts of things that seem nonsensical or morally repugnant to human beings if it does not share our moral intuitions.
If the intelligence of that AI significantly exceeds the range of human intelligence, we may be powerless to stop it or even to comprehend what it is doing. A rogue AI could become a catastrophically nasty Stuxnet, distributing itself across the billions of Turing machines we have networked together. Our only effective response may amount to "erase every data storage device in the world and start from scratch".
Related: http://blog.figuringshitout.com/nov-12th-day-30-no-evil-geni...
Well, yeah. But CERN creating a killer black hole would also be terrible. But we should think about what's probable, not just what's scary.