Amongst other things, this means that how profligate a bank can be in lending money depends heavily on how much all the other banks are lending. So long as all the other banks are lending just as much out and their savings terms are competitive, the outflow of loaned funds will be balanced by an inflow of other banks' loaned funds. What happens in practice is that there's a glut of easy credit during booms which dries up during busts, making the boom-bust cycle worse. You can find some discussion of this here: http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/research/documents/workingpap...
It's interesting to realize that you can create money in the same way that a bank. Just give your friend a promise that you will pay him in the future and he could use it as money with third parties. Most people wouldn't accept it, but that is a different issue.
If somebody is in the mood to destroy more preconceptions about economy I recommend Warren Mosler 'Seven deadly innocent frauds of economic policy', it can be a good introduction to Modern Monetary Theory:
Unfortunately, in the (deadly?) Eurozone this is indeed how it works.
And most don't realize yet.
«In accordance with Article 123 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, overdrafts or any other type of credit facility with the ECB or with the national central banks in favour of Union institutions, bodies, offices or agencies, central governments, regional, local or other public authorities, other bodies governed by public law, or public undertakings of Member States shall be prohibited, as shall the purchase directly from them by the ECB or national central banks of debt instruments.»
Despite that, I can't recommend it enough. It's just after starting to read it that what was going on in the economy of the world made any sense to me.
Also, mainstream economy is just totally wrong in many of its descriptive aspects, but they continue teaching falsehoods anyway. An example at hand is how the fractional banking and the creation of new 'money' by banks works in, virtually, all the modern economies.
This is the reason that the linked PDF by someone a few posts above is so important. They say what Modern Monetary Theory have been saying all the time but the source is the Bank of England.
I think it deserve to be linked again: http://www.bankofengland.co.uk/publications/Documents/quarte...
As Henry Ford said: "It is well enough that people of the nation do not understand our banking and monetary system, for if they did, I believe there would be a revolution before tomorrow morning."
Also, MMT is nothing new or groundbreaking, contrary to their claims. There have been chartalist and endogenous money creation theories for ages, and most mainstream economists are quite aware of them, contrary to the assertions of many MMTers. What separates MMT from the rest is its fusion with more dubious Post-Keynesian theories.
MMT people don't claim it to be any new or groundbreaking, on the the contrary, they claim is just common sense and chartalism. What they claim is that chartalism is true, especially in modern economies. This is a very difficult thing to dispute if you analyze how money works nowadays.
In my experience, the real problem with MMT, is that the implications of what an economy is or how it really works are politically indigestible for a lot of people and inconvenient for a few.
A good reading of the Public Choice journal and similar is a nice antidote to some of the zanier MMT and Post-Keynesian proposals.
I want to return the courtesy, this a reply to critics or MMT: http://www.levyinstitute.org/publications/modern-money-theor...
I have not problem with a lot of post-keynesian ideas by the way.
If anything, you've convinced me more that MMTers believe in a perfect State. Post-Keynesian ideas seem to emanate from it. Kalecki and Robinson were outright Marxists, the former basing their economics on class conflict and the latter praising North Korea and Maoist China. The entire Post-Keynesian literature is devoid of public choice considerations, sans one weak paper from ~2004.
Most critics dismiss the conclusions or address questions that are not really part of MMT.
Personally, I am specially interested in criticism of the most descriptive part of MMT, starting on chartalism but going beyond, banks money creation, sectoral balances, foreign exchange, etc..
(FWIW, I do intend on eventually writing a criticism of Post-Keynesianism in book form, but I'm still in earlier research phases.)
1) Alice deposits $100 in Bank X
2) Bob takes out $900 loan from Bank X and deposits it in Bank Y
3) Charlie takes out $8,100 loan from Bank Y and deposits it in Bank X
4) Eve takes out $72,900 loan from Bank X and deposits it in Bank Y
5) ... the cycle continues ...
Also, I would assume that the interest rates that my bank pays for my deposits would be a lot higher if it could lend out 9x as much as it holds in deposits.
The model where a bank lends out 90% of its total deposits still makes more sense to me and will result in $900 of total money created per $100 initially deposited.
1) Alice deposits $100 in Bank X
2) Bob takes out $90 loan from Bank X and deposits it in Bank Y
3) Charlie takes out $81 loan from Bank Y and deposits it in Bank X
4) Eve takes out $72.90 loan from Bank X and deposits it in Bank Y
5) ... the cycle continues ...
and if you sum the geometric series, which in this case is finite, you get $900 of total additional money created for the initial $100 Alice put in.
If Bob takes cash from Bank X and deposits in Bank Y, Bank X has less cash, that movement is reflected in their balance and in their reserves.
If Bob makes and electronic transfer from Bank X to Bank Y, at the end of the day, Bank X and Y have to clear their balance with each other. As some people have moved money in the opposite direction, from Bank Y to Bank X, the balance could be compensated.
If for some reason, people only retire money from a bank without never making deposits, you have a bank run and it's an indicator of mistrust in that bank.
In summary, though, if we imagine that the bank is required to hold 10% reserve: I go to the bank and get a loan for $900. This is credited to my account. There is no requirement for this money to actually exist. The same day, you go and deposit $100 in actual dollar bills. Your account is credited with $100.
The bank's liabilities are now $100 (in your account) plus $900 (in my account) for a total of $1000. The banks reserve is $100 (real dollar bills you gave them). This is 10% reserve so the bank is legally OK. $900 has been created.
That's how it works. More detail in the PDF I linked.