http://betanews.com/2015/02/22/os-x-ios-and-linux-have-more-...
https://www.gfi.com/blog/most-vulnerable-operating-systems-a...
It's are incredibly misleading, as it:
- doesn't take into account the severity of the bugs; - doesn't take into account the time to fix the bugs, or if they are still open; - bundles some OSs, while separating Windows on several different categories; - compares OSs with incredibly different lifespans; - compares OSs with incredibly different amount of included software.
It's an article created to make Windows look artificially good, nothing more than that.
A product can be secure from malicous attack whilst still leaking information to the Operating System provider, unless of course you don't trust the provider of your OS, in which case you're completely stuffed anyway :)
Microsoft have made a lot of advances in the security field and have a generally good relationship with the security community. In contrast, I would perceive Apple as having a less good relationship with the security community (they're very secretative about what they do, they've taken actions like revoking Charlie Millers Dev creds for pointing out vulnerabilities). Linux is of course not uniform enough to e able to assign a single value to it but there are some potential concerns about their view of security bugs as just being like any other bug...
That's like Apple deputizing OS X's vulnerabilities as "features" and calling it quits.
My test for defining vulnerability derives from whether a reasonable, knowledgeable party would put sensitive information on the system. Windows 10 fails this test. I find it difficult to see how anyone would describe its as "hardened," hence the request for a source.
Windows has been harder to attack than OS X since Vista. I don't think that's changed--Apple is generally slow to correctly implement security features that require kernel changes compared to either the Linux devs or Microsoft.
If I remember correctly, OSX didn't have a good ASLR implementation until 10.9 or 10.10, and has generally lagged behind on OS-level security updates and exploit mitigation (NX pages, ASLR, etc.). It was routinely the first thing hit in the early Pwn2Own competitions (partly because exploits on it were a breeze, partly because the laptop was usually a little nicer and you only got the laptop back then, too--but also because moving from crash to reliable exploit was easier).
I haven't followed security updates in Linux in the past few years as closely, so I can't comment on it as knowledgeably. From what I remember, it was about on par with Windows for difficulty to attack in Vista/7, but there's been a lot of security features that Windows has added since then. From what I remember, a fully hardened Linux box was just as bad to attack as a hardened Windows box, but Windows has generally required less configuration to get that right. (I think SELinux still isn't enabled by default in some distros?)
theqruq had this in one of his slides. I'll try to find the link.
sorry I do not know the meaning of shilling in this context, English is not my native language.
https://grugq.github.io/presentations/COMSEC%20beyond%20encr...