News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by WildUtah on Sunday December 27, 2015 @02:58PM (#10798548)
This law would take the most effective tool against trolls and weaken it without providing any real relief for innovative small companies targeted by trolls.

The post-grant review process is the only way patents get a serious review of their validity. The PTO actually takes printed references found by accused infringers that pay a five-digit fee as reviews the patent. It's essential because the original pre-grant review only allows a few hours of research and examiners are rewarded only for issuing patents so it's hard for one to be bad enough to be rejected.

This bill would make it much harder to revoke patent claims by prohibiting the reasonable interpretation standard. It would also entitle trolls to demand new claims by making trivial adjustments in wording without any serious review so that winners who get bad patents revoked have to immediately face new bad patents.

Meanwhile the loser pays provision is so weak that it provides no hope to small businesses and little to large ones. East Texas judges have already shown it won't apply in their courts.

The pleading requirements have already been enacted by the Supreme Court this month.

This bill has been so watered down that it's worse than the status quo. EFF should oppose it.

Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by throwawaykf05 on Sunday December 27, 2015 @04:13PM (#10798782)
> ... examiners are rewarded only for issuing patents...

This is incorrect. They are "rewarded" for any kind of action on a pending patent, whether it's an allowance or a rejection. Last I checked, a majority of them gets rejected at least once. In some art units (i.e. field of technology) the rejection rates are actually pretty high.

Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by monochromatic on Sunday December 27, 2015 @10:38PM (#10799734)
> Meanwhile the loser pays provision is so weak that it provides no hope to small businesses and little to large ones. East Texas judges have already shown it won't apply in their courts.

They've already shown that something that isn't yet the law won't apply? How have they managed to do that?

Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by roarkjs on Sunday December 27, 2015 @08:45PM (#10799425)
EFF seems to be making a habit of backing these worryingly pernicious bills.
Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by purpled_haze on Monday December 28, 2015 @07:10AM (#10800773)
Could you provide examples? I've not personally heard of the EFF backing anything worrying.
Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by pc86 on Monday December 28, 2015 @10:48AM (#10801622)
worrying != worryingly pernicious

The bill does nothing of substance. That's the problem. It's a waste of resources for the EFF and frankly makes me wonder how they're spending my (and others') money.

Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by bitwize on Sunday December 27, 2015 @09:06PM (#10799481)
They are the most publicly visible electronic rights organization. It would make sense that they'd been compromised a long time ago.
Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by WildUtah on Sunday December 27, 2015 @09:11PM (#10799498)
There is little evidence of that. The EFF is still very valuable to electronic freedom. This bill simply used to be much better in earlier versions.
Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by sneak on Sunday December 27, 2015 @10:47PM (#10799753)
That's true, but the comment was speculation, not accusation.
Re:Stop Patent Trolls: Support the Innovation Act of 2015 by rando289 on Monday December 28, 2015 @03:15AM (#10800375)
"It's essential because", huh, small companies are going to pay 10-99,000 fee? I don't think so. small means that is around the same cost as settling, but it has some unknown % chance of working, wheras settling will work 100%.