News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by refurb on Sunday December 27, 2015 @12:35AM (#10796554)
She says she’d like to see more government-supported media platforms — think public radio — and more robust regulations to keep digital powerhouses from becoming monopolies.

Really? That's the solution? Have the organization that is trying to invade your privacy take over more of the communication methods?

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by karmacondon on Sunday December 27, 2015 @01:47AM (#10796680)
Public radio is government supported, not government run. Meaning, most public radio stations get less than 5% of their annual funding from the government. The rest comes from listener donations and pledge drives, not advertisers, which is pretty much the opposite of what you're suggesting. This is also how Wikipedia works, minus the small percentage of government funding. Not sure if say, Facebook, could operate in the same way, mostly due to hardware scaling and liability issues, but it's possible.
Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by wfo on Sunday December 27, 2015 @01:09AM (#10796619)
Most organizations, especially private ones are trying to invade your privacy. If you think it's only the NSA you are kidding yourself. She thinks corporate surveillance and censorship is a bigger danger than government surveillance. Whether or not you agree with her (I tend to -- you can't vote Zuckerberg out of control of facebook, and he has no responsibility to be accountable or transparent to the citizenry. Facebook is run by orders given from the top, not laws and representatives of the people, it doesn't even pretend to be. Plus, even organizations like NSA have goals which are ostensibly good like 'protect citizens' not simply 'profit') it's a fairly reasonable stance that is not uncommon.

Also the government isn't one organization. It is as wide and varied as the corporate landscape. She may trust NPR which is nominally "the state" (barely) but not NSA or FBI, which is a very reasonable stance to take. The most stringent defenders of privacy I've ever heard of as a class are librarians, who are -- you guessed it -- part of the government. Even agencies themselves are not monoliths; there are many people even at NSA who work in a defensive capacity securing and protecting systems instead of subverting them.

So "More government! That's ludicrous" isn't really nuanced enough.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by jlarocco on Sunday December 27, 2015 @01:48AM (#10796684)
> Most organizations, especially private ones are trying to invade your privacy. If you think it's only the NSA you are kidding yourself. She thinks corporate surveillance and censorship is a bigger danger than government surveillance. Whether or not you agree with her (I tend to -- you can't vote Zuckerberg out of control of facebook, and he has no responsibility to be accountable or transparent to the citizenry. Facebook is run by orders given from the top, not laws and representatives of the people, it doesn't even pretend to be. Plus, even organizations like NSA have goals which are ostensibly good like 'protect citizens' not simply 'profit') it's a fairly reasonable stance that is not uncommon.

That's backwards. Individuals have more control when working with non-government entities because they can opt-out completely. If I don't want Facebook to invade my privacy, I don't have to use it. Problem solved. There's no opting out of the government and NSA invading my privacy.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by wfo on Sunday December 27, 2015 @06:59PM (#10799188)
If you don't want the NSA to invade your privacy, it's easy. Just don't use the internet or email.

That isn't a real solution, just like "opt out of google" or "opt out of facebook" isn't a real solution. When a corporation has a monopoly it's as powerful as a government in that area but with zero accountability or transparency.

The concern here is power. The people in government choosing how to use their power are elected or responsible to someone elected. On the other hand the power structure of a corporation is a dictatorship. Pretending you can theoretically choose to not participate in society and avoid corporate control so their power isn't real power is naive.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by beagle3 on Sunday December 27, 2015 @01:58AM (#10796706)
No, you can't opt out of being tracked by Facebook. By not using it, you stop seeing what Facebook knows about you, but they keep collecting the information through "like" buttons all over the web and through posts and pictures from your friends. Opting out of the Internet is still not enough to avoid the latter
Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by jlarocco on Sunday December 27, 2015 @10:30AM (#10797666)
Actually you can even opt-out of that with tools like AdBlock.

I'm not saying it's a great solution, but it's a solution, and it's more options than exist for opting out of government surveillance.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by beagle3 on Sunday December 27, 2015 @10:31AM (#10797669)
From the "like" button tracking, yes.

From other people posting your pictures and whereabouts? You have to quit civilization.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by jlarocco on Sunday December 27, 2015 @10:33AM (#10797676)
Well you'll have that problem with Facebook or the government, so there's really no difference there.

Doesn't change the fact that it's easier and legal to opt out of Facebook.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by 13thLetter on Sunday December 27, 2015 @12:45AM (#10796570)
It's a weird blind spot a lot of people have. As if a government agency whose budget depends on a perception of ever-bigger threats will be more reluctant to violate people's privacy than Facebook is, or a government agency run by a single political party will report the news more evenhandedly than Fox News does. Large bureaucracies don't magically become trustworthy just because you painted a flag on their side.
Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by cowpig on Sunday December 27, 2015 @01:10AM (#10796621)
> a government agency whose budget depends on a perception of ever-bigger threats will be more reluctant to violate people's privacy than Facebook

What makes you think that a public ISP/whatever would rely on 'ever-bigger threats' for budget?

As far as actual examples, I'm pretty confident in saying that some of the organizations that produce the highest-quality media content are publicly funded. NPR or the BBC are two examples that pop into my head.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by jlarocco on Sunday December 27, 2015 @01:54AM (#10796698)
> As far as actual examples, I'm pretty confident in saying that some of the organizations that produce the highest-quality media content are publicly funded. NPR or the BBC are two examples that pop into my head.

That's a poor argument because it's simply your opinion and you're not giving any evidence to show your opinion is more valuable or more correct than anybody else's.

I can claim the Criterion Collection represents the highest-quality media content ever released, and it's just as valid an opinion as yours.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by RobertKerans on Sunday December 27, 2015 @03:07AM (#10796807)
That's not really your opinion though, it's you publically restating one of the explicit aims of Criterion.
Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by 13thLetter on Sunday December 27, 2015 @03:03PM (#10798568)
> What makes you think that a public ISP/whatever would rely on 'ever-bigger threats' for budget?

Perhaps I was unclear. Facebook will violate your privacy to sell ads. The government agency will violate your privacy to justify its budget. In both cases your privacy is violated, with the additional point that you can't quit using the government agency and if you get in their grill too much they can have you killed.

> As far as actual examples, I'm pretty confident in saying that some of the organizations that produce the highest-quality media content are publicly funded. NPR or the BBC are two examples that pop into my head.

They're very high-quality, and they also generally represent a single minority point of view in their societies. The two qualities are not mutually exclusive.

Re:Techno-skeptics’ objection growing louder by te_chris on Sunday December 27, 2015 @01:17AM (#10796629)
This is so naive. Organisations are as resilient as the way they were designed. Look at public broadcasting across the world: govts in Europe and other places successfully run critical state media.