News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by lotsoflumens on Saturday December 26, 2015 @01:58PM (#10794844)
The very first assertion in the article is "AMERICA’S equity markets are broken."

Do you think that's false? I trade the "markets" every day and I think they are almost completely broken. If HFTs supply liquidity, what do you think happened during the flash crashes of recent history?

Hint: they stopped supplying liquidity. That's why Virtu can make 2 years of trades with only one negative day - a feat that is almost impossible without the front-running advantage that they have.

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by yummyfajitas on Saturday December 26, 2015 @06:24PM (#10795657)
Some HFTs stopped supplying liquidity during flash crashes, others didn't. The ones who didn't were actually the ones to end the flash crash; they see great bargains and buy them up.

The main reason HFTs pull out of markets during flash crashes and similar events is regulatory (broken trades). The only HFTs who can stay in the market during a flash crash are the ones who believe they can predict the retroactive actions of human regulators. Obviously this will only be a small subset of HFTs.

If you want to change this, eliminate the breaking of "clearly erroneous trades". (Japan doesn't have this rule and they do fine.)

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by lotsoflumens on Saturday December 26, 2015 @07:36PM (#10795879)
I absolutely agree - all trades should be final.
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by deadgrey19 on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:22PM (#10795138)
Front running is a technical term. It means to take orders from clients, and then make trades in front of the clients orders, using the information obtained to trade against the client. It's a very quick way to make a profit. It is also illegal. If you have any evidence that Virtu is front running, then you should report them to the SEC to be investigated.
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by PhantomGremlin on Saturday December 26, 2015 @06:07PM (#10795611)
Front running is a technical term

You're clinging to the old definition. Pop culture has generalized the term to mean something different than it used to. It's like the word "hackers".

To throw out a bunch of cliches: that ship has sailed; you can't put the genie back in the bottle; no sense crying over spilled milk. Etc.

I urge you to progress quickly thru the five stages of grief and get to acceptance.

Of course, that's just the layman's meaning. I have absolutely no idea if the meaning of the words "front running" will ever change in a legal sense.

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by deadgrey19 on Sunday December 27, 2015 @05:32AM (#10797045)
It's possible that popularist media such as (Lewis etc) have put forward alternative ideas on what the term means, but if we are to have meaningful discussion, we must agree on what we mean in the context of this discussion. Hence attempting to add a little clarity to discussion before it gets derailed. For the moment at least, wikipedia still mostly agrees with me (whatever that is worth)

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Front_running

If you disagree with my (technical definition) then I challenge you to provide a sound definition from which we can work. I would suggest that simply processing and executing orders quickly on the basis of public information is not sufficient.

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by PhantomGremlin on Sunday December 27, 2015 @06:34AM (#10797146)
I challenge you to provide a sound definition

I'm certainly not up to that task. But I think that lay people are using the term more generally than you are. The Wiki you cite has multiple, expanded, definitions in the section titled "other uses of the term". For example:

   One common practice of high-frequency traders
   (HFT) is a form of front running, where they
   peer into various exchanges and try to detect
   orders as they propagate from a broker's order
   router.
That's not front running by its traditional definition. But that's probably one way that Virtu makes money.

The English language (or is it the American language?) is not static. Words change meaning all the time. E.g. take the word "gay". Once it meant happy, then it became a pejorative, and most recently it has been embraced by the LGBT community. That word sure has changed meanings over the years. Rather, it probably has retained all of those meanings. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gay

Edit: forgot to add this:

I would suggest that simply processing and executing orders quickly on the basis of public information is not sufficient.

Here's an example of using what should be non-public information. Various exchanges, who investors reasonably thought were working on behalf of investors, in the public interest, were instead working for HFTs (from whom they made the most money). Hence "flash" orders, where an exchange would take an order it received from the public and "flash" or show it to its HFT buddies.[1] I don't know if the SEC finally banned that.

How did receipt of my order at an exchange turn into "public" information ahead of its execution?

[1] http://www.wsj.com/articles/SB124940289965505053

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by deadgrey19 on Sunday December 27, 2015 @06:01PM (#10799052)
The English language (or is it the American language?) is not static. Words change meaning all the time.

Naturally, but in a technical discussion about the technicalities of trading technology, we must agree on the meaning, whatever that happens to be.

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by PhantomGremlin on Sunday December 27, 2015 @11:21PM (#10799842)
Yup. I see your point. We especially must agree if we're going to vilify people or claim they're breaking the law.
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by lotsoflumens on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:31PM (#10795175)
That's why I said I agree that the markets are broken. The SEC already knows that this occurs but chooses to not stop it.
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by deadgrey19 on Sunday December 27, 2015 @05:29AM (#10797039)
Either that. Or front running (in the technical sense) is not happening. If it were, other HFT's would pounce at an opportunity to declare a cheat. Occams razor suggests that systemic corruption within the SEC is less likely than the probability that trading operations are operating legally (especially in Virtu's case since they do not even have clients!).
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by yummyfajitas on Saturday December 26, 2015 @06:18PM (#10795641)
Virtu cannot front run; they are not a brokerage.

Folks like E-Trade are the ones who could potentially front-run. Do you have any evidence that they are?

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by lotsoflumens on Saturday December 26, 2015 @07:05PM (#10795782)
Do you understand the purpose of paying for order flow?
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by yummyfajitas on Saturday December 26, 2015 @08:25PM (#10796018)
Yes - you get to trade with uninformed guys making small trades (i.e., folks too small to front-run) rather than informed traders with large amounts of adverse selection.

Do you understand the mechanics of paying for order flow? could you state explicitly (i.e., a sequence of trades) how you believe paying for order flow allows you to "front-run"?

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by consz on Saturday December 26, 2015 @02:46PM (#10795019)
Why do you think Virtu's performance is impossible without "front-running"? Do you not think you would see similar results for any firm with statistically positive EV that makes a large number of trades every day?
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by lotsoflumens on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:01PM (#10795064)
No I don't. Can you name any such "firm"?
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by consz on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:34PM (#10795186)
Sure -- Jump, Tower, HRT, Citadel all have similar results.

Why do you not believe such results are possible? Do you think it's impossible for a firm to have statistically positive edge for sustained periods of time?

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by lotsoflumens on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:42PM (#10795214)
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by consz on Saturday December 26, 2015 @03:47PM (#10795233)
Of course, I think they're the only trading firm named Jump. Is there something particular in that article you wanted to point out?
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by lotsoflumens on Saturday December 26, 2015 @04:06PM (#10795319)
The article speaks for itself ... and anyway your examples are all HFTs.

Of course, having an edge for a long time is possible, even essential. The entire argument here is about having a legitimate edge.

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by consz on Saturday December 26, 2015 @04:44PM (#10795403)
Please be more specific, the article doesn't appear to say anything other than that Jump has no interest in talking about themselves to outsiders (and why should they? They have no customers, they have no reason to publicize themselves). I don't see anything negative in the article.

My examples are HFTs because those are the firms that make the largest number of bets per day, so they have the highest chance of having a day end up being positive (law of large numbers). That's why all the top HFT firms have ~100% positive days. Do you believe that no HFT firms have a legitimate positive edge? If so, do you have any proof that e.g. Jump/Tower/HRT have an "illegitimate" edge?

Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by lotsoflumens on Saturday December 26, 2015 @05:26PM (#10795510)
I usually like a good heated discussion on the interwebs as much as anyone, but when you say: "I don't see anything negative in the article", I realize that I'm wasting my time and I'm already bored.
Re:One Way to Unrig Stock Trading by consz on Saturday December 26, 2015 @06:04PM (#10795601)
I don't see how our discussion is heated. I'm merely asking for specific examples, because reading an article about how quiet and media-averse a particular HFT firm is doesn't ring any bells in my head.