Re:Hierarchy Is Detrimental for Human Cooperation
by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @07:27PM
(#10786440)
> If no one has the ability to listen to the differing opinions of the group and then initiate a course of action by deciding on one or more of the available paths, there are plenty of cases where no consensus is reached and everything goes in a bunch of different directions at once
Organizational structures without hierarchical authority structures, e.g. network models, don't necessarily rely on consensus; they may well have distributed authority where decisions can be made at the point in the organization where the issue is encountered, rather than being kicked up a hierarchy until it reaches someone authorized to make it.
> Now, hierarchy may not produce the most correct decision making, but it does produce decision making (not even "quick decision making", just "decision making"). Nonhierarchical organizations can't guarantee that.
I don't see any evidence that that is particular true of hierarchy as opposed to non-hierarchical organizations. Hierarchical organizations are certainly not incapable of analysis paralysis; having a hierarchy doesn't guarantee a decision.
Hierarchies might promote consistency in the decisions that do get made, but that's a different issue.
Organizational structures without hierarchical authority structures, e.g. network models, don't necessarily rely on consensus; they may well have distributed authority where decisions can be made at the point in the organization where the issue is encountered, rather than being kicked up a hierarchy until it reaches someone authorized to make it.
> Now, hierarchy may not produce the most correct decision making, but it does produce decision making (not even "quick decision making", just "decision making"). Nonhierarchical organizations can't guarantee that.
I don't see any evidence that that is particular true of hierarchy as opposed to non-hierarchical organizations. Hierarchical organizations are certainly not incapable of analysis paralysis; having a hierarchy doesn't guarantee a decision.
Hierarchies might promote consistency in the decisions that do get made, but that's a different issue.