News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @05:22PM (#10786024)
Anyone who follows the work of Randall Wray[1] and Bill Mitchell[2] knows this is a terrible idea. Relinquishing sovereignty of your currency (or pegging it to another currency or commodity) only narrows domestic policy space.

[1] http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=i35uBVeNp6c

[2] http://www.amazon.com/Eurozone-Dystopia-Groupthink-Denial-Gr...

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by mapt on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:15PM (#10786229)
Right. For a functioning economy with a functioning government, functioning central bank, and functioning currency. But that is not Zimbabwe in the 2000's.

Zimbabwe became a dystopian cliché of hyperinflation and societal breakdown, with 80% unemployment and 100% inflation per day. It is the current example we use when we summon up the absurdist "wheelbarrows of currency" imagery. Basically, they were limited to a barter economy, with a thick layer of authoritarian interference in what became a very limited system of production and distribution of goods & services.

To create a currency union that's sustainable, you have to commit to a fiscal union (where there is stable net wealth transfer from New York to Nebraska through things like social security), and/or to a very stiff amount of labor mobility & remittances (where internal migration to the site of available employment is as common as in the Dust Bowl). The EU did not have enough of the latter (for a bunch of reasons), and chickened out on the former; In that case failure was unavoidable, and credit availability simply delayed an inevitability.

You can give up 'monetary sovereignty' in a long-term stable manner and sustain a functioning economy if you're willing to do these things. The United States did. We have whole regions that would be depopulated without social security, Medicare, and welfare to keep the population alive without its manufacturing base. We have abundant internal migration.

But Zimbabwe is a whole other sort of thing. They didn't relinquish much of anything when they gave up their currency; They had to build a new economy from the foundations on up.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by paublyrne on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:49PM (#10786338)
To create a currency union that's sustainable, you have to commit to a fiscal union

I have come to agree with this. I was a supporter of the Euro and Emu since the 1990s, but I think I've been convinced that trying have a single currency without full fiscal union is folly.

You should choose to either have balkanised currencies, or a federal financial bucket, meaning the richer countries subsidise the poorer ones.

We went with Option C in Europe, and I don't have a lot of confidence that the Euro can survive in the long run in the current system.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by HiLo on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @07:19PM (#10786416)
Agreed. I simply can't imagine what would happen if our federal fiscal policy was left up to the 50 states individually. Jesus that would be bad. Texas, my personal and favorite example, would go from an economic powerhouse to unable to support its economy, ever, if anything went south, pun intended.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by polishninja on Thursday December 24, 2015 @12:23AM (#10787220)
I agree. Without a fiscal union, you just have a fixed exchange rate. Look at the Euro for example. Since Greece and Germany make separate fiscal policies but have the same exchange rate (due to the Euro), if their labor force output (GDP) doesn't match then the real cost of the Euro goes up in the lower output country (Greece). They lose the ability to adjust policies based on their current economic situation.

Each separate state in the US has a fixed exchange rate with each other (1 USD = 1 USD), but our fiscal policy is administered by a central authority that adjusts for overall US conditions, not just individual states.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by mapt on Thursday December 24, 2015 @04:40AM (#10787668)
The more interesting take I've read on this is that the financial planners who instituted the Euro certainly saw this coming, and were using it in order to force through fiscal integration a decade or two down the line once they had achieved crisis conditions necessary for massive change.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @07:40PM (#10786470)
Yes to create a stable currency union you need a fiscal union. The EMU is doomed and the Euro along with it.

The answer to the Zim problem is not the adoption of multiple currencies they don't control, though, unless they are just completely abandoning the goal of self governance altogether.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by Turing_Machine on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @10:58PM (#10787043)
"unless they are just completely abandoning the goal of self governance altogether."

That may be exactly what they're doing. Mugabe can't live forever, and his cronies could well be selling the country off to China, with an exit strategy in place to spend the rest of their lives in comfort in a third country.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by polishninja on Thursday December 24, 2015 @12:29AM (#10787232)
They did have control over their currency and looked what happened. The big problem they face now is trust. If they came out with a new currency, no one would trust it enough to use it in everyday transactions. Regaining trust in the government and their currency will take quite some time.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by fspeech on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @11:26PM (#10787115)
Hongkong has a peg to the USD, while China used to. It is not optimal, but I wouldn't say it is unsustainable.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Thursday December 24, 2015 @02:52AM (#10787489)
When China pegged it had completely unassailable reserves of USD. Pegging currency leaves you highly vulnerable to speculative traders and limits the extent to which you can pursue fiscal policy that promotes the prosperity of the populous.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @05:43PM (#10786103)
> Anyone who follows the work of Randall Wray and Bill Mitchell knows this is a terrible idea.

Retiring the domestic currency is an existing policy that this article is only tangentially about.

Adding the yuan to the set of currencies support by the government for public uses given the absence of a domestic currency is the subject of the article.

> Relinquishing sovereignty of your currency (or pegging it to another currency or commodity) only narrows domestic policy space.

Once your currency has so little credibility that no one is using it in practice, its advantage in terms of domestic policy options is minimal, anyway.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:09PM (#10786209)
All you have to do is reissue a new currency just as Germany did and just as Ghana did (and hope you can manage the new one properly!)

Hyperinflation in Zimbabwe was caused by agricultural mismanagement and cronyism. There's no reason they can't fix it except they have shit leadership. Adopting the Yuan DOES, I suppose, remove control from the shit leadership so maybe it's a great idea.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by gozur88 on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:41PM (#10786313)
>All you have to do is reissue a new currency just as Germany did and just as Ghana did (and hope you can manage the new one properly!)

People have to trust you enough to use your new currency, though. Nobody in Zimbabwe is going to trust the government that far without a change in leadership.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @07:44PM (#10786479)
The value of currency is driven by the ability of the government to impose taxes denominated in that currency.

The easiest way to do that in a situation where you are introducing a new currency is to impose land taxes in NewZims.

How will land owners obtain NewZims in order to pay their taxes? They will grow shit and sell it to people for NewZims.

How will people obtain NewZims to buy the produce? By working for the government which will pay in NewZims.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by gozur88 on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @08:13PM (#10786544)
Except that people don't actually need to hold NewZims. If they don't trust the currency (and they won't, not in Zimbabwe), they'll work for dollars, save in dollars, and then on tax day they'll convert just enough dollars into NewZims to pay the taxes. That way they're safe from NewZim currency manipulation.

The only people who'll get paid in NewZims are government workers, and when they get paid they'll rush out to convert their NewZims to dollars that people are selling to pay taxes.

The only way this cycle stops is if the hassle and expense of currency transactions outweighs the distrust of the government's stewardship of the currency. Until that time the NewZim is trading at some huge multiple of the official exchange rate.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by jcrites on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @08:27PM (#10786583)
There was a really interesting Planet Money episode from NPR about how introducing a new currency saved Brazil from hyperinflation. I'd highly recommend it:

http://www.npr.org/sections/money/2010/10/04/130329523/how-f... (podcast and article but I'd recommend the podcast)

They invented a new "virtual currency", stabilized it, denominated goods and services in the virtual currency, built public trust in the conversion rate between the (stable) virtual currency and (unstable, still experiencing hyperinflation) regular currency, and then finally switched the country over to the new currency.

> Four economists wanted to create a new currency that was stable, dependable and trustworthy. The only catch: This currency would not be real. No coins, no bills. It was fake. "We called it a Unit of Real Value — URV," Bacha says. "It was virtual; it didn't exist in fact."

> People would still have and use the existing currency, the cruzeiro. But everything would be listed in URVs, the fake currency. Their wages would be listed in URVs. Taxes were in URVs. All prices were listed in URVs. And URVs were kept stable — what changed was how many cruzeiros each URV was worth.

This was not the only fix, though, as I understand it. The government also had to change its policies that were causing hyperinflation in the first place. However, inflation was continuing more than it should have because the public had lost trust in the currency and assumed it would debase in value every day. The finance ministry needed to regain trust, and the new currency and currency swap allowed them to do that.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @10:14PM (#10786902)
Great story I'm gonna check it out ... Interestingly, though, all money is virtual. In fact, you can think of a currency as a unit of account the same as a metre is a unit of length.

Even in currencies which have notes and coins they only make up a single digit percentage of the total volume of money.

When governments spend, they do so by crediting accounts at a central bank account (ie. They spend their own currency into existence) and taxation is the opposite of this.

The upshot of this is that governments don't need to tax before they can spend (in fact it's the opposite), are not constrained in their fiscal policy by "raising revenue" and have danger of insolvency so long as they only issue debt denominated in their own currency.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by gozur88 on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @08:40PM (#10786630)
Hmmm. That's sort of clever. But this part:

>But, just as important, you have to stabilize people's faith in money itself. People have to be tricked into thinking money will hold its value.

Is the key. I don't see that happening in Zimbabwe until Cap'n Bob kicks the bucket.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @08:23PM (#10786573)
I can't reply to your comment, so I'll reply here (I'm not crazily replying to myself ... )

People need to obtain dollars from somewhere. If the total tax liability in NewZims exceeds the number of dollars obtainable then people will have no choice but to use it.

Also of note is that strong banking institutions are invaluable in this process. If people owe money in NewZims because of money created through private sector lending they'll also need to obtain them from somewhere in order to pay those debts. Making it illegal for banking institutions to hold accounts in currencies other than the national currency is also a means of avoiding this problem (ie. if people want to use banks they need to hold NewZims).

Of course this all hinges on the ability of the sovereign to actually impose sufficient liabilities on the populous in the first place and it would take time for the new currency completely replace the foreign ones but it's doable and is the only road to long term repair of a nation unless they're accepting what amounts to being colonised again.

You can't have sovereign government without sovereign currency.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by crdoconnor on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:34PM (#10786286)
It wouldn't have prevented them from destroying their agricultural sector.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by lmm on Thursday December 24, 2015 @06:53AM (#10787898)
> Adding the yuan to the set of currencies support by the government for public uses given the absence of a domestic currency is the subject of the article.

Doesn't allowing multiple currencies have all the problems of bimetallism?

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by gozur88 on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:39PM (#10786308)
Zimbabwe doesn't have a sovereign currency. Well, it might have one technically, but the de facto currency is the US dollar. It's rarely a terrible idea to admit to reality.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @07:42PM (#10786472)
It's a bad idea to try and solve the problem of hyperinflation by piling on more currencies they don't control (unless they want to just not really govern themselves ... )
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by trhway on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @08:34PM (#10786610)
sounds like you never lived in a country even with high inflation, less hyperinflation.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Thursday December 24, 2015 @02:51AM (#10787487)
I haven't but there are plenty of examples of governments solving hyper or high inflation by reissuing a currency and resolving the cause of inflation in the first place.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by x1798DE on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @05:30PM (#10786059)
Isn't that the whole point? I get the impression that Zimbabwe's policymakers have a terrible reputation, so they are deliberately tying their own hands in order to restore confidence in their currency.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @05:44PM (#10786107)
They are completely abandoning their currency, which is a strange way of restoring confidence in it; it may be a measure to restore confidence in the economy, at the expense of the currency.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dageshi on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @07:22PM (#10786420)
The local currency is already defacto dead, any new currency they introduce will not be taken seriously, they've already lost their local currency.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:10PM (#10786212)
Could well be ...
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by nordsieck on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @05:31PM (#10786062)
Once you've hit hyper-inflation, your options are already equally limited.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dools on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:11PM (#10786218)
Reissue a new currency. Problem solved (well, so long as the root causes of the hyperinflation are also solved ... Which in the case of Zim may not be so ...)
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by foobar2020 on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:01PM (#10786175)
I wonder why so few people in Europe realise that. Despite how bad the consequences are (eg. Greece). Luckily my country (Poland) still prints its own currency and manages its own monetary policy.
Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by dragonwriter on Wednesday December 23, 2015 @06:27PM (#10786275)
> I wonder why so few people in Europe realise that.

I don't think there's ever been any confusion that the adoption of the Euro limits member countries' domestic policy options; people in Europe may have differences of opinions about whether this is a good tradeoff for having a common currency and increasing Eurozone-level policy options, but I don't think many of them fail to realize that limiting local policy options is an effect of the Euro.

OTOH, there's a difference between an upward transfer to a higher-level government that is still accountable to your citizenry (even if their voice is diluted because it is a higher-level government with broader scope) and outsourcing monetary policy to an external issuer.

Re:Zimbabwe's plan to use China's currency by yxhuvud on Thursday December 24, 2015 @06:16AM (#10787824)
It can work as a stop gap measure though, when the local currency is functioning so bad as the one they have now do.

They will be better off switching to their own currency, after their government stop abusing the country.