Re:Turn your checkboxes into iPhone-style binary switches
by m_eiman on Tuesday January 26, 2010 @02:45PM
(#1078589)
Am I the only one who has to think twice every time I see one of those controls; "does the text mean that it's currently off, or does it mean that sliding it over there will turn it off"?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Turn your checkboxes into iPhone-style binary switches
by faramarz on Tuesday January 26, 2010 @02:57PM
(#1078630)
Really? If anything, over the years the use of computers and standard UI's have trained us you to associate light-shades to OFF/inactive and bright-contrast or colour with active/ON.
Re:Turn your checkboxes into iPhone-style binary switches
by ajross on Tuesday January 26, 2010 @04:14PM
(#1078884)
Not as much as they've trained us to associate check boxes with a mark in them with "enabled/on/yes" and empty boxes with "disabled/off/no".
I agree with the grandparent post. This feature trades usability for eye candy. Bad idea.
Re:Turn your checkboxes into iPhone-style binary switches
by there on Tuesday January 26, 2010 @05:09PM
(#1079046)
but in this case you don't see the bright color and "on" part until you slide it, and having to do that just to figure it out is not very intuitive.
Re:Turn your checkboxes into iPhone-style binary switches
by panic on Tuesday January 26, 2010 @02:56PM
(#1078625)
This makes sense if there is a button labeled "off", but in this case the middle of the slider is unlabeled. The part you interact with (at least if the slider were a physical object) is different from the part that displays the state, which sidesteps this ambiguity in a pretty clever way.
Re:Turn your checkboxes into iPhone-style binary switches
by m_eiman on Tuesday January 26, 2010 @03:49PM
(#1078807)
What I see is a button with a grayed out text next to it that says "Off" (or even worse, just "O"). Maybe I'm just damaged from having tried to understand more or less broken GUIs the last twenty years and overthink it :P
Another thing that annoys me with them is that the buttony part doesn't really stand out as a button, I think part of my problem is that I actually interpret the button as the background - and then what I see is an empty space with a button labeled "Off" next to it.
Re:Turn your checkboxes into iPhone-style binary switches
by lanstein on Tuesday January 26, 2010 @05:47PM
(#1079139)
Nope, and the worst one I remember offhand is the mute button on the Treo. Nothing worse than making a comment, looking at the phone, and not being able to tell if you were muted or not.