I'll answer my own question: Users aren't stupid, they just have priorities that differ than those of technology bloggers.
Dismissing your users is an excellent way to ship a frustrating product. Apple has done the opposite, but the use-cases between the masses and the tech elite have drifted far enough that those who don't work on Apple's UX team can drive clicks using smug elitism -- the yin to the 'Apple Fanboy' yang.
why not just edit the grandparent post, rather than waste time with a response?
Try again: are you really mystified by mob mentality?
"Mob mentality" is that assumption. Customers are more than capable of returning their devices to the carrier if they really dislike their devices. They can also sell them, and many do.
But many more do not. Apple's OS is not broken, this blogger just hasn't taken the time to research why people prefer something he doesn't.
Why did people watch Happy Days long after it started to suck? Fonzie Jumping the Shark was two seasons into the pain. But it didn't lose ratings until that episode.
What's popular is not always good. and what's good is not always popular.