News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Analysis of the Backdoored Backdoor by tptacek on Monday December 21, 2015 @08:34PM (#10775052)
The plot thickens: Willem Pinckaers suggested on Twitter that the code as presented doesn't in fact pass Dual_EC's output through the 3DES DRBG at all, but rather (in both versions) directly exposes the output of Dual_EC.

https://twitter.com/_dvorak_/status/679109591708205056

Re:Analysis of the Backdoored Backdoor by XMPPwocky on Monday December 21, 2015 @10:50PM (#10775695)
So is there any plausible reason for using Dual_EC besides "the NSA is paying us off" and "we heard its security is based on the ECDLP so it maybe is harder to break"? From what I understand, it's slower and gives poorer randomness than most other well-established CSPRNGs.

Because, from here, it looks an awful lot like Juniper put their own backdoor in, and the hacker just changed it to let them use it instead. The use of Dual_EC alone, maybe, could be overlooked... but with an implementation bug that just so happens to reveal Dual_EC output directly... something's fishy.

Re:Analysis of the Backdoored Backdoor by tptacek on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @11:42AM (#10778674)
Depends on what you mean by "any plausible reason".

There were cryptographers who could have given you a plausible reason to use Dual_EC --- all of them would have recommended against doing so, though.

But there's no practical reason.

Re:Analysis of the Backdoored Backdoor by adrtessier on Monday December 21, 2015 @08:59PM (#10775211)
Why the statement from Juniper, then? To try to CYA so they don't end up looking as shitty to the community as RSA did post-bribe?

EDIT: The conspiracy theorist in me would say "this is intentional, too." Changing a value to 31 from 32, or adding a single global assignment in a different function, wouldn't be caught on first review most likely, especially since where the '31' is, 31 is also used all over the code to refer to X9.31.

Re:Analysis of the Backdoored Backdoor by sillysaurus3 on Monday December 21, 2015 @11:20PM (#10775801)
Got a link to the 31/32 analysis?
Re:Analysis of the Backdoored Backdoor by hundt on Monday December 21, 2015 @11:50PM (#10775892)
I'm not sure there was a prior "31" but here's the code with the "32":

https://rpw.sh/blog/2015/12/21/the-backdoored-backdoor/