Re:China: The Rapid Rise of a Research Nation
by tokenadult on Sunday December 20, 2015 @11:34AM
(#10767439)
We had visiting scholars from some of China's best institutions
Which Chinese institutions, studying what subject? And, for that matter, who is "we" here? Is your institution a top destination for overseas visits by Chinese scholars?
I would like to see these claims motivated by statistics from the Nature Publishing Group's journals.
Mentioning Nature (the place of publication of the thread-opening commentary) is worthwhile. It appears that Nature has had some submissions from China recently that have had to be withdrawn because the peer review process was compromised.[1]
[1] "'Compromised' peer review hits three papers from Nature Publishing Group" (18 December 2015)
Which Chinese institutions, studying what subject? And, for that matter, who is "we" here? Is your institution a top destination for overseas visits by Chinese scholars?
I would like to see these claims motivated by statistics from the Nature Publishing Group's journals.
Mentioning Nature (the place of publication of the thread-opening commentary) is worthwhile. It appears that Nature has had some submissions from China recently that have had to be withdrawn because the peer review process was compromised.[1]
[1] "'Compromised' peer review hits three papers from Nature Publishing Group" (18 December 2015)
http://retractionwatch.com/2015/12/18/compromised-peer-revie...