News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientific publications should be anonymous by an_ko on Saturday December 19, 2015 @04:29PM (#10764938)
I think you meant s/peer review/replication study/g. Peer review aims to check that papers are publishable, not refute or affirm them by replicating their results; that's a separate process.

I agree shills will eventually get sorted out though. The truth always wins in the end. Just not as fast as just peer review.

Re:Scientific publications should be anonymous by nickff on Saturday December 19, 2015 @04:40PM (#10764985)
Replication should be done more often, and anonymization may serve to catalyze such an increase. Peer review is supposed to examine a paper for flaws, and do so fairly for all authors. This determination of which papers are well thought-out and documented is then supposed to decide which are publishable.

I think you are also tacitly describing a pessimistic view (which I share) of the reality of peer review, that it does not succeed in these lofty aims, and that publishability is influenced by a number of extraneous factors.