Re:Scientific publications should be anonymous
by nickff on Saturday December 19, 2015 @04:26PM
(#10764925)
Peer review is used as a way of determining whether the methodologies or underlying logic used in a study are flawed (in a provable way), and what the severity of the flaw(s) is/are.
>"Peer review isn't... designed to figure out if the results of the study are correct or incorrect."
There is no way of verifying the correctness of most studies and papers; they are simply examined for flaws. I do not see any reason why papers by 'good' authors should be examined less critically than those by 'shills'.
Re:Scientific publications should be anonymous
by icegreentea on Saturday December 19, 2015 @04:43PM
(#10764996)
That's the point. If you publish anonymously then you can publish methodologies and analysis that is up to "gold standard" while completely falsifying/manipulating data.
The current system mostly relies on reputation and professional ethics/pride to filter out that kind of behavior even before the publication stage. The cost to replicate experiments is typically high - even in our current system we cannot replicate to the degree that we want. One presumes that in an anonymous system, the problem would get even worse.
That's not what peer review does. Peer review isn't investigative journalism, nor is it a criminal trial, nor is it designed to figure out if the results of the study are correct or incorrect.