News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secret Code Found in Juniper's Firewalls Shows Risk of Go... by stickfigure on Saturday December 19, 2015 @04:28AM (#10763124)
I'm confused. Are these accidental vulnerabilities or deliberate backdoors? If deliberate, why is there speculation about who might have installed this "secret code"? Do they have version control? Is there a specific human attached to the relevant commits? Serious question.
Re:Secret Code Found in Juniper's Firewalls Shows Risk of Go... by detaro on Saturday December 19, 2015 @07:03AM (#10763354)
> If deliberate, why is there speculation about who might have installed this "secret code"?

Would you take whatever your VCS claims as face value in this case? I wouldn't, which makes answering this very difficult, so I think it is to be expected that they don't have an answer yet.

Re:Secret Code Found in Juniper's Firewalls Shows Risk of Go... by hackuser on Saturday December 19, 2015 @03:32PM (#10764733)
I wonder the same thing, but with enough resources, there are many ways to attack version control. For example, probably there are exploits in the VCS system and in the database that underlies it, they could steal a developer's credentials or hack his/her account otherwise, attack the compiler ...

Think of the value of all the data in the world that Juniper firewalls protect. Of course every actor that can afford to will invest the resources to introduce back doors. As an example, the NSA had ~30,000 employees and a ~$10 billion budget as of a few years ago; they can afford to do it.

For me, the real question is, how does Juniper address the fact that they are such a target? Do they take adequate security measures for the situation (which would be very expensive)? Just take standard security measures, which very likely would be inadequte, so they can escape liability? How does any such organization deal with it?: Google, Microsoft, Apple, Apache, Linux, etc.

Re:Secret Code Found in Juniper's Firewalls Shows Risk of Go... by enlightenedfool on Saturday December 19, 2015 @05:22AM (#10763203)
They might know the person, but not necessarily their affiliation. They might want to investigate before they divulge. If it's a US person, it takes time or would never be divulged.
Re:Secret Code Found in Juniper's Firewalls Shows Risk of Go... by andreyf on Saturday December 19, 2015 @04:37AM (#10763135)
And a good one. They were definitely deliberate, but the other details are not public.
Re:Secret Code Found in Juniper's Firewalls Shows Risk of Go... by jubes on Saturday December 19, 2015 @04:45AM (#10763150)
If this wasn't an intentional backdoor it raises the question, what source control methods were being used and are they secure? Has Juniper been compromised on a larger scale?
Re:Secret Code Found in Juniper's Firewalls Shows Risk of Go... by andreyf on Saturday December 19, 2015 @08:09PM (#10765620)
That's a good question, too. I'm sure people are asking it and many others like it internally, a well.

On the outside, I think this is yet another reason to use git, which, if I recall correctly, is designed to make attacks on commit history significantly more difficult than they are with SVN and CVS.

Re:Secret Code Found in Juniper's Firewalls Shows Risk of Go... by hyperdunc on Saturday December 19, 2015 @06:50AM (#10763337)
This is a very important point. Are the backdoor(s) traceable to a specific event or individual? How far up the company hierarchy does the rot go? Whatever the answer, it is insufficient. We are relying on hardware and software that is opaque at the network level, and therefore open to this sort of manipulation.