News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:08PM (#10761320)
The freedom to make choices, and the knowledge of your choices.

Sure, you just described a lack of knowledge... But she ALSO had the financial freedom to make the choices she wanted.

That's well above "poor" in my mind.

You're describing someone who thought they were poor. Sure, yup, some people are there. But many people are ACTUALLY poor - and the claim was that it's better to be ACTUALLY POOR TODAY, than RICH twenty years ago. I don't buy it.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vinceguidry on Friday December 18, 2015 @10:23PM (#10762471)
You're not quite getting my point.

Sometimes the difference between being ok and standing on your own feet and being downtrodden boils down to knowledge. You're trying to move the goalposts on what 'poor' means, and you keep having to move them because the Internet makes life so much easier that you have to actually be pretty much homeless before it'll qualify for your definition of 'poor'. People like the lady in my story, when they don't have access to social contact and information, fall prey to psychopaths because they perceive they have no other options. The psychopaths take their money and their dignity and leave nothing left. Then sure, they'll fit your definition of poor.

You know what was nice when I was a kid and we were bouncing around from apartment to apartment because my mom kept losing jobs? My Nintendo. My mom won the money to buy it from a radio contest and managed to convince a coworker to sell one to her. It was the only thing I wanted for Christmas that year.

Children, at least the ones I grew up with, are awful, status-conscious, hateful things. They're much better now, but there was no love lost between me and my peers growing up. We bemoan the distractification of America, but I gotta tell you, I'm eminently grateful that I could escape those horrible little shits into a brightly colored world where practice and patience earned you reward after reward.

I had books, and read the ones I had plenty, but having that Nintendo was just the greatest thing in the world for me.

I've seen firsthand how technology curbs violent impulses, raises moods, defuses tense relationships. Distraction from your problems is a real, take-it-to-the-bank luxury when you have no control over your life.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Friday December 18, 2015 @11:57PM (#10762696)
You're not getting my point.

YES, ABSOLUTELY, sometimes it boils down to knowledge. But MOST OF THE TIME, it DOESN'T.

I'm not moving the goal posts. I said poor, and then you wanted to talk about people who aren't poor, but think they are, and if you educate them, it turns out they're not poor.

> They're much better now

Dude, not cool. Do you have a paper towel I can use to clean the milk off my screen? You just made me spit all over.

And now you're moving the discussion between having KNOWLEDGE, and having TECHNOLOGY. Those are, in fact, different things.

And let's just BACK UP.

Let's pick that kid with a Nintendo. Which was, of course, more than 20 years ago. Is he really THAT much better off with an XBox One today?

And please remember, the target we're discussing is "poor today versus RICH 20 years ago." RICH. As in, if you want it, you buy it. If you need information, you hire people who research it for you. If you are ill, you go to the best doctors in the world. RICH. In 1995. Rich in 1995 ain't too shabby. In fact, I'd say it's much better than poor in 2015.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vinceguidry on Saturday December 19, 2015 @12:51AM (#10762790)
> And now you're moving the discussion between having KNOWLEDGE, and having TECHNOLOGY. Those are, in fact, different things.

That is, in a nutshell, the difference between 20 years ago and today. They used to be different. Now they are not. Having the technology eventually exposes you to the knowledge. Knowledge now is completely free if you live in the US, because of free access to technology. Between Wikipedia, Craigslist, various social media outlets, there is no way you can be on the Internet today and not find what you are looking for, if it's important to you, eventually. Very much not the case in the 90s.

This has a direct effect on the experience of being poor.

> Is he really THAT much better off with an XBox One today?

Yes, because society was that much worse 20 years ago. What you were escaping was that much more awful.

> Rich in 1995 ain't too shabby. In fact, I'd say it's much better than poor in 2015.

I would rather be 30 and poor today, than 30 and rich in the 80s. You may disagree, but I was not very well off not that many years ago, and I was able to leapfrog what would have been decades of hustling to get where I am now, because of advantages that I wouldn't have had 30 years ago.

You're right, 30 and rich in the 80s isn't too shabby. But that would mean that I would have 30 fewer years of life in today's world. You're completely discounting the value of time and over-valuing money. 30 years is an unimaginably enormous amount of time. I can get 100x the value of my time out of a year here than I could have with any amount of resources in the 80s. If I chose to be 30 and rich in 1985, that means I would be in my sixties today. Being young in today's world is worth, to me, any amount of money you can name.

I'm reminded of the fact that things we find totally boring today were fine luxuries in the Middle Ages. Chairs were the domain of the medieval super-rich at one point in time. The conversation we are having right now likely could not have existed 30 years ago.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Monday December 21, 2015 @12:26PM (#10772179)
Here, I'll name a few things a rich person could do twenty years ago that a poor person today could not:

Visit the Seven Wonders of the Ancient World.

Visit the Seven Wonders of the Modern World.

Go to Cannes Film Festival.

Go to Pixar movie premiers.

Personal chef.

Personal masseuse.

Back-stage passes to go see amazing rock legends, many of whom have died by now.

Influence politics.

Invest in corporations, like SOLAR power, WIND power, NUCLEAR power. Fund start-ups.

Help stabilize and transform former Soviet Block countries.

Fly a Mig.

Visit the Galapagos islands.

See a living White Rhino, up close.

Swim with dolphins.

Swim with green sea turtles off Maui.

Eat at Mama's Fish House on Maui, one night, and stay overnight in Hana so you can wake up early and visit the seven sacred pools bright and early.

Walk the Great Wall of China.

Go to the Olympics.

Ride a hot air balloon.

So, let's come back to what you said.. "100x the value"??? Come on. Name TWO things a poor person can actually do today, that would make them tangibly HAPPY, or tangibly BETTER OFF that a rich person couldn't do 20 years ago.

> The conversation we are having right now likely could not have existed 30 years ago.

First, you're moving the goal-posts, the discussion is 20 years ago. And second, nonsense. I was active on well over 100 BBS systems.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vinceguidry on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @10:29AM (#10778249)
I don't understand your point. I could care less about any of these things. A few of them I would rather not do, even had I the option. Life contains a series of problems that need to be solved. If you solve them adequately, then you are happy and fulfilled. If you don't solve them at all, then you are unhappy. It's as true for the rich as it is for the poor.

How to attain personal fulfillment. How to leave a legacy. How to earn the love of your family, friends, and community. How to retain a sense of control over your destiny. You can do all of these things with or without the wealth that would allow you to go to Cannes. You can fail to do them even if your personal masseuse is also your mistress. You can even do them if you're poor.

Having the easy access to information that today's Internet offers means you don't have to limit yourself to your own mind, your own efforts.

Fly a Mig? Christ man, talk about missing the point.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @10:47AM (#10778347)
> Life contains a series of problems that need to be solved.

And MOST of the problems that MOST people face, have already been solved by the time someone is rich. As in, seeking food, seeking shelter, seeking transportation, clothing, future security...

> If you solve them adequately, then you are happy and fulfilled.

That's not how my life works. My daughter just had heart surgery. It cost over $50,000. My cut of that was about $2,000. It saved her life. You still think I'd rather be POOR today?

> If you don't solve them at all, then you are unhappy.

In my experience, there are two broad types of people - those who imagine how happy they'll be after they accomplish their list of tasks (you), and those who are generally happy and find a way to put joy into the things they're doing (me). Since I'm generally happy, the gravy for me is getting to experience more out of this life and help other people.

> How to earn the love of your family, friends, and community.

I don't believe I do "earn the love of my family, friends." I think my family and friends love me unconditionally.

> How to retain a sense of control over your destiny.

We're talking about POOR today. ACTUALLY POOR. And ACTUALLY POOR people do not have nearly as much control over their destiny as you're painting.

> Fly a Mig? Christ man, talk about missing the point.

I specifically asked you to name TWO things a poor person can actually do today, that a rich person couldn't do 20 years ago. You're full of criticism for my point of view, but I've given you a terribly simple challenge, and you have not risen to it. If you want me to understand your point, then try STATING your point (via examples), rather than criticizing mine.

And to defend myself, I find that in debate it's best to try to understand the most charitable rendition of the other person's argument. You're breezing right past several of my points: "Influence politics. Invest in corporations, like SOLAR power, WIND power, NUCLEAR power. Fund start-ups. Help stabilize and transform former Soviet Block countries." Those are all, in how I view them, about helping people. Most of my other ones were based on the fact that a rich person isn't struggling to survive, and is instead seeking to squeeze as much out of this life as possible. Carpe diem. And evidence points to helping people, and having unique experiences, as being far more enjoyable than merely having possessions. So, if I picture myself as rich 20 years ago, I come up with things (for that list) that a poor person could not do today, but that would make me happy.

If you want to attempt to convince me, then why don't you try to list concrete examples of things a poor person could do today, that a rich person 20 years ago could not do. Since that's the actual topic at hand.

And fine, let's take the most charitable form of your argument - Having The Internet Is Awesome. Fine. 2 billion people have access to the Internet. That means roughly 5 billion people do not. Perhaps the agreement that you and I can make is that it would suck to be poor, among those 5 billion people today.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vinceguidry on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @12:29PM (#10779005)
Not sure why I'm continuing this discussion. You seem to be too invested in having your own view of what I was saying instead of discussing what I was actually trying to say, despite any number of clarifications. I'll try one more time then give it up.

> And MOST of the problems that MOST people face, have already been solved by the time someone is rich. As in, seeking food, seeking shelter, seeking transportation, clothing, future security...

Most people think these things are granted by personal wealth. Students of history and geopolitics know better. The US is a rich country with political and economic innovations allow for a kind of security people in other countries only dream of. No amount of personal wealth can hedge against political upheaval, hell, wealth makes you a target more often than not. Personal wealth gets you the ability to fly a Mig. National wealth is having enough ambient wealth in every single community so that starvation is really rare.

I was just reading an article where the author's grandma's grandma had gotten thrown out onto the street by their landlord in the middle of the winter. The whole block banded together and chipped in a coin out of their own meagre lives so they could rent that room for one more month. Had that happened in any other country, they would have frozen to death. That's national wealth, that's what is really helping the poor. In other countries, you have to have personal wealth.

Our country has only gotten richer and richer in the last thirty years. Again, practically invisible to anyone not specifically looking for it, it's hard to see the forest for the trees. But it's there, and I'm telling you, if it were me, I'd rather lose everything and become homeless today, than to step into a time machine with a barrel full of time-appropriate cash. I'm not making that decision for everybody. Just me. Sure, it would suck for awhile to claw myself out of poverty. But over the long run, I believe I'd be better off. Barrels of cash aren't all that hard to come by. Massive national wealth isn't, and it's the national wealth that I'm basing my conviction on, along with my own understanding of my abilities.

> That's not how my life works. My daughter just had heart surgery. It cost over $50,000. My cut of that was about $2,000. It saved her life. You still think I'd rather be POOR today?

I don't want to dissect this too much because it's your daughter and I want to be respectful. But my point is that national wealth created both the option to have heart surgery and the ability to have it relatively cheaply. We can dive into that all day long if you like. These days the not-so-well-off crowdfund these kinds of major life events, it's just another way of getting wealth to where it's needed, same as passing around the hat allowed the aforementioned author's great great grandmother not freeze. Of course, you have to have insurance to get the option for heart surgery, maybe, plenty of children's charities out there, this is an open problem that the nation is trying to solve.

To cut you off, of course the not-so-well-off isn't the ACTUALLY POOR. (you really seem to have a complex over this, as if I don't know the difference or something) But again, the only thing that really solves the poor's problems is national wealth. There's not enough liquid wealth to spread around to stop poverty.

> I think my family and friends love me unconditionally.

Hehehe, good thing you live in a country where the things that can seriously test that belief in unconditionality generally don't happen. Totalitarian states insert politics into families specifically to keep these sorts of bonds from giving communities the power to resist the state.

In case you missed my point, it's that just about everything you think of as 'you', your life, your wealth, your family, your very mind, is a product of the country you live in. And it's not a sharp division between ACTUALLY POOR and whatever the opposite of that is, it's an immensely varied gradation and ecosystem of abilities, disabilities, the services that make those disabilities less onerous, the efforts to spread information about those services, government programs, communities, the well-meaning and charitable, and the options people have available to pull themselves out of poverty. There is a ton of attention being paid to the actual problems both poor people and ACTUALLY POOR people are having, and a lot of resources devoted to promising options.

> We're talking about POOR today. ACTUALLY POOR. And ACTUALLY POOR people do not have nearly as much control over their destiny as you're painting.

You are talking about that. I made an assertion concerning my own convictions that you are taking out of context. Now you are asking me to substantiate my own convictions using your weird funny logic. Nothing about being poor keeps you from helping people. Most of those volunteering in soup kitchens are closer to the people they're serving than they are to you. And the things rich people try to do to help the less well-off often boil down to ego gratification and do no real good.

> If you want to attempt to convince me, then why don't you try to list concrete examples of things a poor person could do today, that a rich person 20 years ago could not do. Since that's the actual topic at hand.

I can't even begin to try to convince you because the very way you think about wealth is utterly silly.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @01:46PM (#10779485)
> The US is a rich country

And it was almost identically rich 20 years ago. Actually, since the national debt keeps going up, and we've engaged in multiple wars since then, a case could be made that we're worse off.

> National wealth is having enough ambient wealth in every single community so that starvation is really rare.

So, maybe what you meant to say was, "I'd rather be what most people consider to be poor today (as long as I got to live in the United States), than rich twenty years ago."

> Our country has only gotten richer and richer in the last thirty years.

I disagree. We had the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression. People were genuinely hurting. Employment among many groups (such as "poor" laborers) hasn't rebounded. Meanwhile, 20 years ago was in the middle of a boom.

> I'd rather lose everything and become homeless today

...as long as it's in the United States. (Which you did not clarify in the first place.)

> I'm not making that decision for everybody. Just me.

Sure, but you presented your argument as rational, not just personal. And then for some reason you were BOTHERED that I tried to understand your position. Why state your position, if you don't want other people to take it seriously and try to understand it?

> Barrels of cash aren't all that hard to come by.

All evidence points to GENERATIONAL poverty being the norm. So, yes, wealth IS that hard to come by.

> Massive national wealth isn't...

Far out. So, as a rich person 20 years ago, you'd move to the nation with the greatest national wealth.

> But my point is that national wealth created both the option to have heart surgery and the ability to have it relatively cheaply.

And my point is that TWENTY YEARS AGO, the United States wasn't THAT different than it is today. In fact, relative to median income, the same medical procedures cost more today (even adjusting for inflation) than they did back then. By a LOT. And most outcomes aren't proportionally better. We're still way behind in life expectancy and infant mortality, for instance.

> as if I don't know the difference or something

No, I'm trying to understand your statement, "I'd rather be poor today than rich twenty years ago." I'm trying to actively listen, and keep asking you if I'm understanding you correctly, even to the definitions of each of those words "poor" that I use in my head.

> But again, the only thing that really solves the poor's problems is national wealth. There's not enough liquid wealth to spread around to stop poverty.

That's a great assertion to digest, and I don't buy it. There are nomadic people, to this day, living in areas of Africa we'd be tempted to call a desert, who work less than 10 hours a week gathering food, seeking shelter. They spend the rest of their days lounging, chatting, teaching their children. If there is enough food and water to provide for a population, everything else is relative, isn't it? They even take care of their neighbors when they are sick.

> Hehehe, good thing you live in a country where the things that can seriously test that belief in unconditionality generally don't happen.

Let me imagine the worst imaginable environment - I'm a Jew, living in Nazi Germany. I think my friends and family still unconditionally love me. Are you convinced they don't?

> Totalitarian states insert politics into families specifically to keep these sorts of bonds from giving communities the power to resist the state.

So, again, I think you should have said, "I'd rather be what most people consider to be poor today (as long as I got to live in the United States), than rich twenty years ago."

Because if you and I made a list of all of the poor people in the world today, I think you'd be forced to agree that MOST of them live in places you would not ever want to live. No national wealth. Totalitarian government. Warlords. Corruption. Not enough food and water. No opportunities for employment, or education. No internet.

> In case you missed my point, it's that just about everything you think of as 'you', your life, your wealth, your family, your very mind, is a product of the country you live in.

In case you missed my point, the US twenty years ago isn't THAT different from the US today, to offset the difference between being able to financially provide for my family, and NOT.

> the options people have available to pull themselves out of poverty

But they don't. All the data says you're EXTREMELY likely to have the same wealth as your parents.

I think, in order for your assertion to make any sense, you must believe that most people are poor because they're not as motivated as you are. I'm not even trying to load that statement, or put judgement on it. That's the only way I can make sense of what you've said.

> There is a ton of attention being paid to the actual problems both poor people and ACTUALLY POOR people are having, and a lot of resources devoted to promising options.

I don't buy it. Even our beloved veterans are homeless, unemployed, and suicidal. I'll think the options are promising when they start to have an impact. And I mention veterans, because even Conservatives claim to want to use government to help poor people, as long as they're veterans. But we still haven't put a dent in it.

> I made an assertion concerning my own convictions that you are taking out of context.

No, you made an assertion, and I want to discuss it, to see if it was rational, and to try to gain knowledge from whatever perspective you have.

> Most of those volunteering in soup kitchens are closer to the people they're serving than they are to you.

Most of the people stocking soup kitchens are more like me. Disposable income, secure in their career. And twenty years ago, there were more people like that (relative to population size), than there are today. The middle is shrinking.

> And the things rich people try to do to help the less well-off often boil down to ego gratification and do no real good.

A rich person is CAPABLE of doing everything a poor person can. You may be right that the rich need to be educated.

> I can't even begin to try to convince you because the very way you think about wealth is utterly silly.

/sigh

Thanks for the insult.

WHY BOTHER talking, if you don't ENJOY talking with people who think differently than you? SERIOUSLY?

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vinceguidry on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @02:23PM (#10779715)
> And it was almost identically rich 20 years ago. Actually, since the national debt keeps going up, and we've engaged in multiple wars since then, a case could be made that we're worse off.

I could argue against all of these points, but it seems like that would be pointless.

> So, maybe what you meant to say was,

I would rather lose absolutely everything (including things that have helped me out in the last 20 years like family assistance. the idea is that I have to go by my wits as much as possible) and stay in today's USA than step into a time machine with any amount of money to mid 1980s USA. I believe that, just by relying on national wealth, I could become as rich as I wanted to in relatively short order in a way that would have been impossible 30 years ago. You don't think the world's changed all that much but I do. We seem to lack the shared vocabulary needed for me to convey why I think that way.

> ...as long as it's in the United States. (Which you did not clarify in the first place.)

I did, in another part of the thread. I thought you would have been thoughtful enough to follow the rest of the discussion to get the missing pieces of my argument. A lot of times I'll, not just look at the whole thread, but also click to see some of the author's other conversations to see where he / she's coming from.

> So, as a rich person 20 years ago, you'd move to the nation with the greatest national wealth.

Maybe. Depends on how much I have tying myself down there. The aforementioned author's great great grandmother had brothers that died in the Holocaust rather than emigrate from Latvia because they had a thriving local business there. Elon Musk brought himself and his family over from South Africa, that's how much he believed in national wealth. I'm not sure I would come to the same conclusions so quickly, and Musk did have a really ugly childhood that he was anxious to escape. I perhaps might have found a local maximum rather than a bigger pond. Or perhaps not. I don't have the experience of growing up in an emerging market to draw on to be able to make a real guess. I can only judge based on my current awareness.

> I think my friends and family still unconditionally love me. Are you convinced they don't?

It's one of those things you don't know until you know. Or you know until you don't. Do I think it's possible you're miscalculating these feelings? Certainly. I do know that you haven't carefully considered the full breadth of things that could affect your relationships. What if part of your brain shut down and you became a different person than you were before? Read an article where that precise thing happened recently. What is it precisely that your family loves about you and what would happen if that thing were to be taken away? If you delve into that question, I think you'd find that each member of your family has different values and would react differently to each kind of stress. You'd also have to figure out what unconditional love is and how to define the event of that love going away.

Things get a lot more difficult when you apply real logic to mushy situations.

> the US twenty years ago isn't THAT different from the US today

I very much disagree.

> All the data says you're EXTREMELY likely to have the same wealth as your parents.

Data does not predict anything. It only describes what has happened. In a certain light. If you examined the data yourself and asked your own questions of it you might come to a different conclusion.

> Most of the people stocking soup kitchens are more like me.

How do you know this? Have you gone and looked? Have you asked a significant number of them their stories and how they came to volunteer? I'll admit my assertion in this regard is probably about as valid as this one. But that's how you find out.

> Even our beloved veterans are homeless, unemployed, and suicidal.

What that means is that the mental problems caused by going to war are worse than we have the ability to effectively help, at this moment in time. But there's plenty of research going into things like PTSD so that we can more effectively help these people. Suicide is an extremely difficult problem to solve.

> WHY BOTHER talking, if you don't ENJOY talking with people who think differently than you? SERIOUSLY?

I do enjoy it. There are any number of things I could have done with my morning, I chose to focus my attentions on this discussion.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @02:36PM (#10779811)
> I thought you would have been thoughtful enough to follow the rest of the discussion to get the missing pieces of my argument.

I didn't take the time, this time. I let your words to me stand on their own, and they weren't standing up very well. I repeatedly asked, and you didn't clarify some of the apparently very important nuances of your view point.

> Data does not predict anything.

That's ridiculous.

The entire history of science has been gathering data, and making predictions. The predictive power of science is ASTOUNDING. Even without a deeper understanding of the underlying mechanisms. Newton and Keppler invented formulas that fit the data they had at hand, and the predictions they made were uncanny, even though they didn't understand the actual forces that were creating those phenomena.

> How do you know this?

By answering the phone call when soup kitchens were desperate for donations, by helping my family when they were stocking, by volunteering my own time and money when I had the spare time and money, and by looking at the other people who were similarly stocking the shelves.

Sure, it's anecdotal.

> I do enjoy it.

If you enjoy it, then please refrain from the negative comments ("the very way you think about wealth is utterly silly"). I doubt they increase your enjoyment, and they negatively impacted mine.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by vinceguidry on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:01PM (#10780000)
> I didn't take the time, this time. I let your words to me stand on their own, and they weren't standing up very well. I repeatedly asked, and you didn't clarify some of the apparently very important nuances of your view point.

I didn't take the time to elaborate on questions you asked that I felt like I'd already addressed elsewhere. If I had known you didn't bother to read them, I would have briefly restated them.

Oh well.

> The entire history of science has been gathering data, and making predictions.

You missed the hard part of actually testing those predictions. Data science does not bother testing, it just collects more and more data. Often the premises change right underneath, and data science just goes right on lamp posting.

An excellent blog to watch this in real time is Slate Star Codex. The author will make you reconsider everything you know about science if you listen to him long enough.

> by looking at the other people who were similarly stocking the shelves.

You just looked at them? You didn't get to know them? Appearances can be very deceiving, especially when it comes to public settings like that. I'm not saying you're wrong, but I've learned to not trust other people's perceptions if there's nothing more to go on.

It doesn't matter to me that it's anecdotal. I've learned that anecdote can be more trustworthy than 'scientific' analysis. But one needs to learn how to draw conclusions from anecdote and where the holes in the logic might be before relying on it.

The people at the soup kitchen may have been putting on their best faces to go out. Without knowing their stories you don't know why they're there.

I worked at the Atlanta Community Food Bank for a short time. I maybe was the only person on the team actually getting paid. I went in with one perception of the people that were working there, and left that place with a completely different perspective after talking to them and getting to know them.

> If you enjoy it, then please refrain from the negative comments ("the very way you think about wealth is utterly silly"). I doubt they increase your enjoyment, and they negatively impacted mine.

My suggestion to you, since you did say that you were here to perhaps learn from my experience, is to be a little more critical of your own understandings. It took me a long time to come to my current understanding of what wealth is, and I'm sure that understanding will evolve further as I delve more deeply into topics like economics and finance to flesh out what I feel is a strong historical understanding. I didn't gain that understanding by believing in myself, I did it by disbelieving in my own thoughts.

If someone told me that the way I think about X was silly, I'd immediately want to know why he felt that way. Hearing the rationale of people that have negative opinions of me is quite valuable to me. For someone whose been on BBSes for the last 20 years, I'd have thought you've have acquired the same thick skin that I have regarding intellectual discussions. I apologize for offending you, but as I don't think I did anything wrong, it's obviously a hollow apology.

Re:The Upward Redistribution of Income: Are Rents the Story? by VikingCoder on Tuesday December 22, 2015 @03:46PM (#10780293)
> You missed the hard part of actually testing those predictions.

No, I didn't. "Gathering data" includes "testing previous predictions."

> Data science does not bother testing, it just collects more and more data.

You just gave yourself permission to disregard any evidence I present. That level of arrogance should terrify you, once you realize you have that blind spot.

> The people at the soup kitchen

I said "stocking." As in, paying for the building, the lights, and the food.

> My suggestion to you, since you did say that you were here to perhaps learn from my experience, is to be a little more critical of your own understandings

My suggestion to you, is to not call people "silly" when they disagree with your understandings, and disregard any evidence they present.

> If someone told me that the way I think about X was silly

The way you think about the improvements in wealth in the United States in the last twenty years is silly. Specifically, how it impacts the lives of the poor. I'd be glad to continue providing evidence, but I'm not convinced you'll be bothered to investigate it.

> For someone whose been on BBSes for the last 20 years, I'd have thought you've have acquired the same thick skin that I have regarding intellectual discussions.

When I see someone ignoring data, not responding to specific requests for clarification, and throwing insults... I have way less tolerance for the insults.