We live in such a highly regulated world that I can't help but chuckle when someone blames the "free market" for many of the problems of today.
We live in such a bought-and-paid-for world that I can't help but chuckle when someone blames the "government" for many of the problems of today.
This is a tautology.
Interestingly, from a legal perspective free speech does go hand in hand with what the Court's call the market place of ideas[1] which generally should act like the free market.
"The marketplace of ideas is a rationale for freedom of expression based on an analogy to the economic concept of a free market. The "marketplace of ideas" holds that the truth will emerge from the competition of ideas in free, transparent public discourse."
Do you have any examples of "actual" free markets?
The reality is that you cannot have completely free markets in a democracy. As soon as a signifcant minority (let alone majority) do not like the market's outcome, they will petition a legislative alternative to that outcome. So of course there's going to be a hybrid system. Is there any 1st world country with a less interventionist government in economics than the U.S.? There are plenty of 3rd world countries where there's no regulation at all, I don't see entrepreneurship flourishing there, rather it's exploitation, and might makes right.
But that presupposes that the populous would dislike the free market's outcome, which if anything points to the idea that free markets are unworkable in a practical sense.
Hong Kong, which is widely applauded by neo-Liberal economist Milton Friedman for it's low taxation and hands off regulation, has a hidden secret, they raise most of their revenue from land leases. To clarify, in Hong Kong the only piece of freehold land belongs to Saint John's Cathedral.
> Article 7 of the Basic Law of the Hong Kong Special Administrative Region (HKSAR) stipulates that the land and natural resources within HKSAR shall be state property.
Same goes for Singapore, they meddle continuously in the real estate economy through the HDB. Ethnic quotas in state owned buildings ensure Singapore's racial harmony.
It's questionable whether either country could survive without their neighbors (China and Malaysia) whom they import most of their goods from.
Interestingly, Denmark and Canada surpass the United States, according to the IEF. I was aware the former has the least regulated banking sector, but not much beyond that.
The term "free market" does not imply that there are not courts of law or private property rights. Perhaps too many think "anarchy" when they read "free market."
A "free market" is an attempt to simulate a perfect market, which is a theoretical construct that doesn't exist. One of the things it requires is perfect information among all parties in the buy and sell process. Courts and property rights are one way of trying to simulate that perfect market, and thereby create a free market. But this isn't actually working well enough, is the book's argument, there's still an imbalance that favors exploiters, i.e. the free market isn't providing enough information for buyers to make properly informed decisions rather than manipulated ones.
I think you might have meant perfect competition. Free markets don't need perfect competition, either. That's just a neoclassical assumption, again for modeling convenience.
Courts of law don't provide any recourse for abuses in trade unless there are laws regulating trade.
Which certainly addresses things like conversion (the civil parallel to theft), but doesn't address consumer recourse, which is what was asked about and is expressly about trade.
A: A completely free market would not require food labelling, meaning that protein contents would be unrecorded. Therefore, there would be no point in adding melamine.
Q: What does the free market say about the addition of fillers such as sawdust to food?
A: If such fillers are in such quantity as to affect the quality of the food, the food product will command a lower price in relation to other, higher quality products. If not, well, no harm, no foul.
Q: What if there are no higher quality products? What if the manufacturers collude, implicitly or explicitly, or if the costs required to enter the market prevent competition?
A: The market will adapt to use other products. Too much sawdust in your bread? Eat cake.
When an economy has a strong central bank meddling with the interest rates, firms and individuals receive an incorrect signal in the time-preference for money, since the interest rates are not determined by the market. Coupled with an inflationary monetary regime and Keynesian ideology throughout, the "free market" has no chance to produce optimal outcomes.
Come back with a book that examines actual free markets and we'll talk.