Mahmud pointed out an excellent example of that happening and I have seen plenty of others.
Go visit the last page of the 'new' section and have a look at all the stuff that was lost. It's really a pity.
And plenty of 'fluff' does get upvoted.
HN only needs 2 votes to get something on the front page. Not all interesting topic will hit the FP, and not everything I consider interesting is also true for others.
Its not perfect system, mostly because, in this case, perfect is subjective.
For instance I absolutely dislike ~90% of Tech Crunch crap posted here, but I have to live with the fact that others find Tech Crunch drama interesting.
i.e.
First 2 minutes? 1 upvote.
4 minutes: 2 upvotes
6 minutes: 3 upvotes
8 minutes: 4 upvotes
etcBut it's not a set time or point scale, it's based on what's currently on the front page, how old those stories are, and how many points they have.
The one thing I do agree with is that after a certain timeframe, I do wish even the most popular stories decayed more quickly.
I'd say the Sivers and the asmartbear posts would hit the front page, if they were featured there even for a second.
The asmartbear post on what you need to do at a tradeshow is now at 2 points, and no where near the front page.
The Sivers post on building intimacy is now at 3 points, and is also nowhere near the front page
You could make the front page longer, of course, but then I'm sure some set of people would complain about that.
Usually 1 upvote is enough for a story less than an hour hold to get a shot.