News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by mrob on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:19PM (#10755007)
Even if that's true, imagine an AI as smart as John von Neumann on modafinil, that never thinks about food/sex/art/etc., that never sleeps, that has access to Wikipedia etc. at the speed of thought, and no morals. That's not uncontrolled intelligence explosion level disaster, but it's still highly dangerous.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by Chathamization on Thursday December 17, 2015 @09:29PM (#10756237)
But maybe it think about art a lot. Or maybe we can't cut out sleep without harming our ability to reason. Or maybe the AI would be more interested in watching youtube videos than working in the field of AI.

The only human level general intelligence we have to look at is humans. Sure, it's possible that there's an easy way to build an artificial intelligence that doesn't need to sleep and isn't interested in art but that retains our ability to problem solve; but maybe their isn't. It's possible that we'll be able to easily figure out that alternative brain architecture and build in the near future; but given how little we still don't understand about our own brain (and the failure to mimic the brains of even simple creatures), it doesn't seem likely. It's possible that if we were able to overcome those major hurdles, a super John von Neumann would be able to wield enormous political power; or it's possible that, like the real von Neumann, it would focus mostly on its research.

In order to get to the AI doomsday scenario, you have to assume that a lot of very unlikely things are all going to happen. And the main argument for them happening seems to be one of ignorance - "hey, we don't have any idea what this will be like, so we can't say that this improbable situation won't happen."

Re:Should AI Be Open? by lmm on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:49AM (#10757804)
I'd say your ideas are more unlikely. You can't generalize from one example. An AI that hasn't gone though evolution is extremely unlikely to have the exact set of complex wants and needs that humans have.

And even if you're right, as Alexander says, in that case why the need to open-source it? If you think it's important that AI is open-source and not controlled by e.g. Facebook, that must be because you think AI is going to be powerful and effective. In which case it's as dangerous as he says.

Re:Should AI Be Open? by Chathamization on Friday December 18, 2015 @09:09AM (#10758464)
But it's not a generalization from one example; I'm giving a string of different possibilities, based on the fact that we only have a single point of data. People seem to readily except that particular scenario - the "AI as smart as John von Neumann on modafinil, that never thinks about food/sex/art/etc., that never sleeps, that has access to Wikipedia etc. at the speed of thought, and no morals" scenario - based on zero evidence that an AI would actually be like that.

People seem more ready to accept the idea that an artificial general intelligence would act similar to it's portrayed in SciFi stories than accept that it might act similar to the other general intelligences we can observe (namely ourselves).

Re:Should AI Be Open? by lmm on Friday December 18, 2015 @09:32AM (#10758606)
But all of your possibilities are ridiculously human-parochial. And they all boil down to "the AI might have diverse interests", which is very unlikely - we have them as a result of evolution, but an AI created by human programmers would very likely have only one driving interest. And whether that interest was food, sex, art, or some particular notion of morality, the result would be equally terrible.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by murbard2 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @05:31PM (#10755081)
A virtual campus with thousands of hyperfocused John Von Neumanns collaborating telepathically and accomplish subjective years of works in seconds of real world time.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by vectorjohn on Thursday December 17, 2015 @06:31PM (#10755493)
The assumption being that these John Von Neumanns will only require cheap, modest hardware to run on.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by cousin_it on Thursday December 17, 2015 @06:56PM (#10755630)
If we have a Von Neumann level intelligence running on a supercomputer, and we haven't solved friendliness by then, we've lost the future of humanity. As far as I can tell, all arguments against that conclusion are based on various kinds of wishful thinking.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by murbard2 on Friday December 18, 2015 @09:50AM (#10758711)
Yo, dawg, I heard ya like Von Neumann architecture.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by vectorjohn on Thursday December 17, 2015 @06:30PM (#10755482)
And still I doubt that AI could talk its way out of a prison.

It could be dangerous though.

Re:Should AI Be Open? by apsec112 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:25PM (#10756004)
Someone tried this experiment, with a human playing the "AI" and another human playing the "guard". The "guard" let the "AI" out.

http://www.yudkowsky.net/singularity/aibox/

Re:Should AI Be Open? by mziel on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:52PM (#10756105)
And yet Big Yud refuses to publish the conversation. I know his arguments (unknown unknowns) but this is a very un-scientific approach and frankly why should we believe that what he said happened really happened?
Re:Should AI Be Open? by apsec112 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:35PM (#10756448)
"And yet Big Yud refuses"

Please don't try to argue by name-calling. A strong argument is stronger without it.

"DH0. Name-calling.

This is the lowest form of disagreement, and probably also the most common. We've all seen comments like this:

    u r a fag!!!!!!!!!! 
But it's important to realize that more articulate name-calling has just as little weight. A comment like

    The author is a self-important dilettante. 
is really nothing more than a pretentious version of "u r a fag."" - http://www.paulgraham.com/disagree.html
Re:Should AI Be Open? by lifeformed on Friday December 18, 2015 @02:47AM (#10757247)
That didn't seem like name-calling to me.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by zyxley on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:01PM (#10756341)
Exactly. The lack of actual information is a reason to disbelieve Yudkowsky on this topic, not to assume that it's true for Secret Technophile Mystery Cult Reasons.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by isolate on Thursday December 17, 2015 @10:23PM (#10756406)
I think it's probably true and that the secrecy is more about cult building.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by astrofinch on Friday December 18, 2015 @12:30AM (#10756829)
Could be wrong, but I believe in most cases the conversations were with users of the SL4 mailing list, and at least one user posted a PGP signed statement to the effect that the AI was let out of the box.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by fallingfrog on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:02PM (#10756554)
Bet he offered the subject 500 dollars real money.. That wouldn't be cheating either. Any decent ai would think of the same thing. And it would explain the secrecy.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by apsec112 on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:16PM (#10756591)
The page I linked has him explicitly denying doing that.

"The AI party may not offer any real-world considerations to persuade the Gatekeeper party. For example, the AI party may not offer to pay the Gatekeeper party $100 after the test if the Gatekeeper frees the AI... nor get someone else to do it, et cetera. The AI may offer the Gatekeeper the moon and the stars on a diamond chain, but the human simulating the AI can't offer anything to the human simulating the Gatekeeper. The AI party also can't hire a real-world gang of thugs to threaten the Gatekeeper party into submission. These are creative solutions but it's not what's being tested. No real-world material stakes should be involved except for the handicap (the amount paid by the AI party to the Gatekeeper party in the event the Gatekeeper decides not to let the AI out). (...) In case you were wondering, I (Yudkowsky) obeyed this protocol voluntarily in both earlier tests."

Re:Should AI Be Open? by mziel on Friday December 18, 2015 @12:48AM (#10756883)
Yes, I'm aware of that. But without 3rd party we're basically trusting the participants that it didn't happen.

E.g. "I'll give you $500, but you also have too sign an NDA, so that people don't know we cheated."

I don't want to imply that they cheated, just want to reiterate my original argument that the lack of transparency makes the experiment effectively invalid. Think Tesla and his claims about World Wireless system.

Re:Should AI Be Open? by fallingfrog on Friday December 18, 2015 @07:05AM (#10758014)
I didn't notice that! If that's what he says then I'm willing to believe that they played by those rules.
Re:Should AI Be Open? by lmm on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:20AM (#10757711)
We have a signed admission from the other side. We have one published conversation log (not from Yudkowsky).
Re:Should AI Be Open? by mziel on Friday December 18, 2015 @05:46AM (#10757798)
See other comments. Signed admission doesn't mean anything without 3rd party verification.

I've never seen a published log. Link?

Re:Should AI Be Open? by lmm on Sunday December 20, 2015 @03:36AM (#10766499)