News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RxJS is great. So why have I moved on? by WorldMaker on Thursday December 17, 2015 @03:51PM (#10754447)
RxJS will automatically dispose/unsubscribe in composition scenarios: for instance, if you flatMap from one "underlying" observable to a sequence of observables, when you unsubscribe from the "underlying" observable it will observe any remaining (if any) hot observables that were kicked off by the flatMap.

RxJS also automatically disposes resources when an observable completes and maybe that's a part of what you are missing in the observable lifecycle and part of why you've felt that RxJS has an equivalent of "manual memory management"?

Yes, lots of streams are effectively infinite in nature, but that doesn't mean that all of them are, and a completion signal can still be useful and informative, including in lifecycle management. (It also helps keep the duality between Enumerable/Iterator worlds and Observable/Observer worlds.)

One obvious case that I see a lot in applications where finite streams/observables show up in great number is that Promise (Task/Future) is essentially an observable that produces one result and completes.

Re:RxJS is great. So why have I moved on? by davexunit on Thursday December 17, 2015 @04:41PM (#10754769)
>RxJS will automatically dispose/unsubscribe in composition scenarios

But it still requires manually unsubscribing from something in the first place. I just think that's the wrong approach to FRP. The graphs are actually static, but dynamic behavior is needed for developing at the REPL.

Re:RxJS is great. So why have I moved on? by WorldMaker on Thursday December 17, 2015 @04:57PM (#10754875)
Thus far I've only had to manually dispose a single RxJS observable, and that turned out to lead me to a better composition strategy and I got rid of the manual dispose.

If I'm working in a REPL I set things up to "naturally complete" with some useful sample set, just as if I were working with potentially infinite enumerables. In RxJS that would typically be something like myObservable.take(5).