News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: A competitor stole my iPhone app content — what s... by anonjon on Monday January 25, 2010 @09:43AM (#1075170)
Do nothing? This isn't worth it.

Spend your time/money making an application that isn't so easily duplicated. You said it yourself that you weren't planning to make a mint on this. No point in dealing with the hassle of lawyers, paying the lawyers etc.

If you only had one competitor, it would be possible, but being that you have five competitors, and some of them are free, I'd have to say that the market is saturated and its time to get out anyway.

Re:Ask HN: A competitor stole my iPhone app content — what s... by Eliezer on Monday January 25, 2010 @11:22AM (#1075371)
He's certainly not worth trying to sue. But he's worth reporting to his school, publicly nailing to the wall, and the resulting story posted on one's website to discourage anyone thinking of ripping off future apps, if that can be done. Remember, the expectation of punishment for misdeeds like this is an expensive public good, those who maintain it are social altruists.
Re:Ask HN: A competitor stole my iPhone app content — what s... by cabalamat on Monday January 25, 2010 @11:50AM (#1075442)
Agreed. Philip Kirwan -- http://www.philipkirwan.ie/site/index.html -- is clearly a dodgy person. I certainly wouldn't do business with him.
Re:Ask HN: A competitor stole my iPhone app content — what s... by pistoriusp on Monday January 25, 2010 @01:13PM (#1075687)
I don't understand - From the link you provided I can't tell if he's a dodgy person or not?

Sure - He have the submitters story, but he hasn't provided us with evidence beyond a reasonable doubt that Philip has stolen his database.

Re:Ask HN: A competitor stole my iPhone app content — what s... by Padraig on Monday January 25, 2010 @02:26PM (#1075880)
You can verify this for yourself, but it'll cost you the price of both apps: about $7.

1. Buy them, right click on both apps in your iTunes Apps list and choose 'Reveal in Finder'.

2. Copy both to your desktop.

3. Rename them to .zip and unzip them

4. Click on the app file and choose 'Show Package Contents'

5. Compare dublinbus.db with dublinbus.png2

They are not totally identical, but there is a very significant overlap that cannot be down to chance.

Also, his e-mail to me admits that he copied my 'layout'.

Though, I agree that his website doesn't him look 'dodgy' by itself.

Re:Ask HN: A competitor stole my iPhone app content — what s... by cabalamat on Monday January 25, 2010 @06:38PM (#1076555)
> From the link you provided I can't tell if he's a dodgy person or not?

That wasn't my intention. my intention was that when someone Googles his name they'll get lots of pages saying he's a dodgy person.

Re:Ask HN: A competitor stole my iPhone app content — what s... by nym on Monday January 25, 2010 @07:41PM (#1076692)
He overuses absolute positioning. Clearly dodgy.