News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The discovery of lunar water has changed everything for h... by jerf on Thursday December 17, 2015 @08:40AM (#10751363)
This opinion was born and raised in an environment of government funding for space. There is no fundamental reason why it should cost dozens of billions of dollars to get to space. If private industry brings it down to a cost more related to the true, fundamental price, it goes flying out the window. Merely millions to put people in space is of a kind with oil exploration, building transport networks, and all sorts of other situations where private industry under solid government routinely invest by the millions or even billions. At that point the argument actually completely flips around; anywhere we can afford to put a human, it is more cost-effective to do so than send a robot.
Re:The discovery of lunar water has changed everything for h... by adrusi on Thursday December 17, 2015 @11:47AM (#10752531)
This is wrong. The fact is we take our humans back, but leave our robots in space. It's harder and more expensive to prepare a return voyage, and the robots can ultimately spend more time in space and for some applications that means it will be more effective at gathering data.
Re:The discovery of lunar water has changed everything for h... by jerf on Thursday December 17, 2015 @01:24PM (#10753261)
"Anywhere we can afford to put a human", and I'll remind you, that's under the new, wildly cheaper domain of space flight, not the current one. If only a robot is affordable at all, there's no debate about which is "better". Clearly that is not the argument being made, though, because then there's no point in even repeating the line about robots being more cost effective.

If space flight is cheap, you're better off sending a far more capable human than a robot, because if you're going to spend $3million for a robot or $5million for a human, the human is going to be more than 40% more effective than a robot. It's a totally different story than when the difference is $12billion or $500billion.